View Full Version : Spanish Church to remove Moor-slayer saint
seruriermarshal
05-03-2004, 09:21 PM
Spanish Church to remove Moor-slayer saint
A statue in a Spanish cathedral showing St James slicing the heads off Moorish invaders is to be removed to avoid causing offence to Muslims.
Cathedral authorities in the pilgrim city of Santiago de Compostela, on Spain's north west coast, plan to move the statue to the museum.
Among the reasons for the move is to avoid upsetting the "sensitivities of other ethnic groups".
From (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3680331.stm)
Spain crazy ?
Truthsayer
05-03-2004, 09:23 PM
http://www.militaryphotos.net/forums/viewtopic.php?t=13867
Already posted by another muslum-hater.
SeanAshi
05-03-2004, 09:25 PM
Already posted by another muslum-haterWhat classifies them as "muslim hater"?
Truthsayer
05-03-2004, 09:40 PM
By the same logic who anyone that buys american, plannes vacations in america, has american friends and generally likes american people can be determined to be anti-american since they doesn't 100% support the current goverment.
SeanAshi
05-03-2004, 10:03 PM
ahhh sarcasim...Israelis including?
foxtrot023
05-03-2004, 10:05 PM
Spanish Church to remove Moor-slayer saint
A statue in a Spanish cathedral showing St James slicing the heads off Moorish invaders is to be removed to avoid causing offence to Muslims.
Cathedral authorities in the pilgrim city of Santiago de Compostela, on Spain's north west coast, plan to move the statue to the museum.
Among the reasons for the move is to avoid upsetting the "sensitivities of other ethnic groups".
From (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/3680331.stm)
Spain crazy ?It is being changed by another statue of the same saint, without the sword and dead moors. The current attack of political correctness by the socialists.....
Javehn
05-04-2004, 01:39 AM
http://www.militaryphotos.net/forums/viewtopic.php?t=13867
Already posted by another muslum-hater.
How someone can be that ****ed up ? Muslim Hater ? I know more Muslims then you will meet in the rest of your misserable life .
Congratulation gaylord , you are my new official target .
M1A2U2
05-04-2004, 02:02 AM
Its art work, why dont we get trid of Michael the Ark Angel slaying the demons because it is offensive to devil worshippers.
WanderingNomad
05-04-2004, 03:08 AM
Do the Muslims have Saints killing Christian crusaders?
I don't know, I'm just curious.
Hmmm... maybe we could formulate here a list of the politically non correct artworks, traditions or historical events and persons? Huh?
My nominations:
- "Othello" - W.Shakespeare
- Battle of Poitiers 732
- Battle of Lepanto 1571
- Battle of Vienna 1683
- "Idiot" - F.Dostoyevski (as it may insult all the idiots of the World)
:cantbeli:
Spain crazy ?
Do the Muslims have Saints killing Christian crusaders?
Nope. Islam and Judaism are the only true religion: 1 God, 1 religion, so they don´t have the so called "Saints", that only are heathen little gods exclusive of catholics heathens et alia.
Spanish are crazy, we always were crazy, look at my name. And answering in this thread to another thread written by the dirtiest mouth of this forum, I think we the spanish are afraid, in fact we´re terrified because Ariel Sharon and Yaser Arafat are going to get married together and having the ultimate hater-antispanish semitic baby of the world that one day will Re-Re-Conquer Al Andalus/Sepharad again. Just now, I´m wet because I pissed in my pyjama of terror.
Just because of that, spanish with the surname "Matamoros"(Moorkiller) are going to change it for the more political correct surname of "I´m a chicken" and in some cities of Castilla where they say in Easter "killing jews" in the place of "drinking liquor" now they´ll say: "forgive us Abraham". And just because Santiago(Saint Jacob) is a semite saint and it´s perverse to have a semitic saint killing his semites brothers, in Spain we´re gonna change him by other God of War more accurate to the actual situation, we´re thinking in "San Manolo" or "San Paco", perhaps "San Tio Pepe", there´re many candidates.
But I´ll keep myself shouting "SANTIAGO Y CIERRA ESPAÑA"(Santiago please shut the door, the weather is cold) when I charge agaisnt infidels.
Shalom, Salaam.
http://www.unf.edu/classes/freshmancore/coreabroad/pictures/2001Santiago/Santiago-cathedral-interior-matamoros-PH2357.JPG
Javehn
05-04-2004, 07:24 AM
And answering in this thread to another thread written by the dirtiest mouth of this forum
Ehm , why did i recieved that honnor ? :roll:
I feel i little over reaction here . The question is simple , why it was done . No need for sarcasm , if you can't answer normally .
I didn't read the official news , i heard about it . And wanted to set it straight .
KalleBalleSvartSk@lle
05-04-2004, 07:35 AM
Spain crazy ?
Do the Muslims have Saints killing Christian crusaders?
Nope. Islam and Judaism are the only true religion: 1 God, 1 religion, so they don´t have the so called "Saints", that only are heathen little gods exclusive of catholics heathens et alia.
Spanish are crazy, we always were crazy, look at my name. And answering in this thread to another thread written by the dirtiest mouth of this forum, I think we the spanish are afraid, in fact we´re terrified because Ariel Sharon and Yaser Arafat are going to get married together and having the ultimate hater-antispanish semitic baby of the world that one day will Re-Re-Conquer Al Andalus/Sepharad again. Just now, I´m wet because I pissed in my pyjama of terror.
Just because of that, spanish with the surname "Matamoros"(Moorkiller) are going to change it for the more political correct surname of "I´m a chicken" and in some cities of Castilla where they say in Easter "killing jews" in the place of "drinking liquor" now they´ll say: "forgive us Abraham". And just because Santiago(Saint Jacob) is a semite saint and it´s perverse to have a semitic saint killing his semites brothers, in Spain we´re gonna change him by other God of War more accurate to the actual situation, we´re thinking in "San Manolo" or "San Paco", perhaps "San Tio Pepe", there´re many candidates.
But I´ll keep myself shouting "SANTIAGO Y CIERRA ESPAÑA"(Santiago please shut the door, the weather is cold) when I charge agaisnt infidels.
Shalom, Salaam.
http://www.unf.edu/classes/freshmancore/coreabroad/pictures/2001Santiago/Santiago-cathedral-interior-matamoros-PH2357.JPG
You could convert to protestantism :) then your statues of saints could be conscidered works of art.
Bytw, I think Islam is against making pictures or impressions of humans as they're made by God as an impression of him, and we all know (atleast some of us know) that making pictures of God is a big no-no, so there are probably no stautes of moors killing christians or jews.
big80a2
05-04-2004, 07:35 AM
A Spanish friend of mine say's he feels betraid by the politicians.
He say himself that it was week to leave Iraq.
Jeez what a sad day, what's next destroying castles of our crusaders because it might be offensive against muslims. This is without doubt one of the most stupid things ever done.
Instead we should show all everyone that we are proud of what we have achieved troughout history instead of crap like this.
Hmmm... maybe we could formulate here a list of the politically non correct artworks, traditions or historical events and persons? Huh?
My nominations:
- "Othello" - W.Shakespeare
- Battle of Poitiers 732
- Battle of Lepanto 1571
- Battle of Vienna 1683
- "Idiot" - F.Dostoyevski (as it may insult all the idiots of the World)
:cantbeli:
- the "Rolandlied", a german saga of a knight who fought against the muslims in the pyrenees.
WanderingNomad
05-04-2004, 08:58 AM
Didn't Ashcroft order the statue of 'Justicia' to be cloaked because it was a **** woman??? So much for religious political correctness ...
If it's okay to censor such a statue because of nudity it's okay to censor a statue that celebrates a massacre as well. be it a religious or whatever massacre.
MARINO
05-04-2004, 09:20 AM
You are becoming to understand how are the Spanish :(.
This statue has been there during centuries, so why we change it now, i'm sure that only few mslims, and also people of other countries knew about it it's a no sense.
2Sheds_Jackson
05-04-2004, 10:06 AM
Didn't Ashcroft order the statue of 'Justicia' to be cloaked because it was a **** woman??? So much for religious political correctness ...
If it's okay to censor such a statue because of nudity it's okay to censor a statue that celebrates a massacre as well. be it a religious or whatever massacre.
If I remember right - he had it cloaked because he used to conduct press conferences in the rotunda & the "tit" would appear right over his shoulder and was a bit distracting. It created an involuntary suclkling response in the males watching, and Ashcroft's message was being ignored as everybody's eyes were transfixed on the enourmous marble nipple.
I'm trying to find out the status on this - I wonder if it's still covered...
Mamon
05-04-2004, 10:28 AM
This is a disgrace to us. It's been a part of our (Spanish) social and religious tradition for hundreds of years, now the socialists are ordering this to be removed. What are they going to do next, ban Semana Santa now because it's going to offend non-Christians? Grrrr :fork: :bash:
Hola Mamón! Excuse if I´m wrong, but Santiago is in Galicia, and there the ruling party is that you know, and the sculpture of Santiago is inside the cathedral, and in the cathedral the only authority is the archebishop, so I think talking here of socialist is out of point, ok?
MARINO
05-04-2004, 03:53 PM
Por cierto Loco ZP Zapatero no hizo la mili.
chauncy republicans
05-04-2004, 04:00 PM
Didn't Ashcroft order the statue of 'Justicia' to be cloaked because it was a **** woman??? So much for religious political correctness ...
If it's okay to censor such a statue because of nudity it's okay to censor a statue that celebrates a massacre as well. be it a religious or whatever massacre.
Ashcroft is very anti-****. lol
Argyll
05-04-2004, 04:04 PM
I got a genuine question here..........how many Muslims are likely to go into this Cathedral anyway?
Is it like a museum type thing?
Do Muslims enter other religious dwellings as a rule?
Por cierto Loco ZP Zapatero no hizo la mili.
So, am I the only spanish here who did the military service? Really, we´re gonna being invaded by the barbarians again, what a decadence! Still I think the new elected government in Spain can´t rule inside of any cathdral, a polish who lives in Rome wouldn´t let them to do that.
got a genuine question here..........how many Muslims are likely to go into this Cathedral anyway?
Is it like a museum type thing?
Do Muslims enter other religious dwellings as a rule?
Well, the point with Santiago´s cathedral is that it´s in the northwestern point of Iberian Peninsula, and when the muslims invaded Spain in 711 only a little northern fringe, all mountains, were free of them, so with the help of fortune the tomb of Saint James Apostle was discovered a century later, this was a historical feat of that time in all Europe, then began a route of pilgrimage from all europe to Santiago of Compostela, the route when crossed the Pyrinees was threatened by muslims expeditions which periodically attacked the north of Spain in the summer. The Pope said that going to Santiago was as good for your soul like going to Jerusalem or Rome.
The same Charlemagne peregrinated to Santiago, in fact the defeat of Roldan, who commanded his rearguard, happened when he came back to France, only that the defeat of Roldan, wasn´t against the muslims but, ehem, the basques. The road to Santiago became like an umbilical cord linking the still weak spanish kingdoms with the rest of Europe. All the route to Santiago, which began for northerns europeans in Paris, became a rich zone, with new towns, cities, hospital for pilgrims and castles for the warriors who defended the pilgrims against muslims, it was like the Crusades only that 2 centuries before, and many colonist stablished and reinforced the area. Tha Califas of Cordoba knew the growing importance of Santiago, so they tried to destroy the city and they did it at the end of XI, but it was their last hit because after that all the Califate suffered a political crisis and blow up in about 300 little muslims kingdoms which were eaten by christians one by one, and in few time Santiago cathedral was rebuilt.
It was said that Santiago descended riding a white horse and killing moors in the battle of Clavijo, but even this battle is not sure that happened. The case is that Santiago The Pilgrim became Santiago Matamoros.
The spanish christians kingdoms were many times rivals, but the Santiago route was the commom factor oftenly and so Santiago became like a spanish God of War. The spanish cavalry and infantry usually shouted just before charging "Santiago y cierra España", something meaning like "Saint James and Spain backing you" whenever they fought, although the rivals were moors or english or indians. When Hernán Cortés was retreating from Mexico after the Sad Night he had to figh with few survivors in Otumba battle against the whole aztec army, and a historian, Gómara, said that Santiago Matamoros again helped spanish soldiers, but one of this veterans who wrote his own history of the battle, Bernal Díaz, said he couldn´t see Santiago riding his white horse, only aztecs everywhre. The man buried in Santiago Catedral is posibly a christian heterodox beheaded during the roman empire, but it doesn´t matter, what it cares is that Santiago Route was vital for the survival of northern Spain, and I suppose the muslims of today know that fact.
Of course the tourists can visit the cathedral, you don´t need to be christian, like in the rest of christian temples in Spain. It´s only the mosques that can´t be visited by no-muslims, because we´re contaminated, you know.
The sculpture of Santiago now replaced I don´t think it was replaced because of Ben Laden, but because of PC reasons, because it was near the tomb of Santiago if I remember well, and just because of many non christian tourists visit that cathedral the archebishop want to show a more kind image of Santiago. But there´re many Santiagos Matamoros everywhere in the same city and in other places.
http://www.uchile.cl/cultura/mapa/temporales/religiosidad/images/Ayacucho.jpg
This Santiago is in Ayacucho, Perú.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.10 Copyright © 2012 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.