PDA

View Full Version : Thatcher: Fears About Hong Kong Handover Largely Proved Groundless



J-10
06-22-2007, 05:15 PM
http://biz.yahoo.com/ap/070619/britain_thatcher.html?.v=1
Tuesday June 19, 1:21 pm ET
Thatcher: Fears About Hong Kong Handover Largely Proved Groundless

LONDON (AP) -- Former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher has said her fears that Hong Kong's economy could not prosper under Chinese Communism have proved to be largely groundless.

She said she has not been disappointed by Hong Kong's development since Britain handed over the former colony to China a decade ago.

"I think we must be realistic," Thatcher said in a rare interview broadcast Tuesday by British Broadcasting Corp. radio.

"Let's think over a moment how great our private worries were about what would happen in Hong Kong after the handover. Now those worries have largely proved groundless."

Thatcher, an ardent advocate of free markets, said she believed that economic freedom could not thrive without political freedom. "But the pace at which this occurs will depend on what happens within China itself," she said.

Britain formally withdrew from Hong Kong on June 30, 1997.

Thatcher, who was prime minister when the deal on Hong Kong's future was signed in 1984, said the "one country, two systems" principal devised by former Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping was the key to an agreement about the colony.

"'One country, two systems' was developed some years earlier as an approach to the issue of Taiwan. I have to say that it doesn't look any more appropriate in that context now than it did then," Thatcher said.

"Nor did it at first seem to me the way ahead for Hong Kong. What I wanted was a continuation of British administration. But when this proved impossible I saw the opportunity to preserve most of what was unique about Hong Kong by applying Mr. Deng's idea to our circumstances.

"In fact, I complimented him on his brilliance. It's often a good idea to tell people with whom you negotiate that they were right all along."

Thatcher, 81, has made few public comments or appearances since suffering a series of strokes five years ago. This month, however, she taped a message to British forces to mark the 25th anniversary of the Falklands War with Argentina, as well as being interviewed by the BBC.

vinny_121_ND
06-22-2007, 06:40 PM
People from Hong Kong miss the British. Their presence really helped their economy, and being that financial district of Asia. We simply don't understand the rationale of why some people in afghanistan and iraq don't want the british helping them out. If you don't want the brits, send them to hong kong.

Hispeed1
06-23-2007, 01:12 AM
Well, the system in Hong Kong is different than mainland China... Hong Kong=Special Administrative Region.

IraGlacialis
06-23-2007, 01:44 AM
People from Hong Kong miss the British. Their presence really helped their economy, and being that financial district of Asia. We simply don't understand the rationale of why some people in afghanistan and iraq don't want the british helping them out. If you don't want the brits, send them to hong kong.
It's most likely because of the stigma of possible imperialism. Even though Hong Kong was grew to be a jewel compared to the rest of China, you have to admit that some places did not fare well under colonial rule.
I'm betting that in the beginning, the residents of Hong Kong didn't want the Brits there either, especially that they weren't there for just rehabilitation, but to claim a spot that was taken over.
Plus, I'm betting that many of the Iraqis and Afghans, even though it is hardly seen in the media, do appreciate the efforts of the of coalition foces.

BTW, I think the fears of handing HK back to China we justified, and a big reason those fears were proved to be unnecessary were because HK & Macau and the rest of China are practically seperate from each other.

chardson67
06-23-2007, 12:57 PM
Well the Chinese even planned/thought of invading Hong Kong 3 times during the Cultural Revolution, PLA soldiers were over the border and were ready for it (from a recent news report from TVB Pearl). I guess the UK made a good move by handing over Hong Kong "back" to China, to prevent future confrontations.

Anyways it would be very hard to defend Hong Kong (if the brits were still here) if it was attacked by China today, imagine PLA troops parachuting in thousands, en-massing armor and blockading Hong Kong's waters with it's submarines! This would be like Falklands, but Falklands located in arms reach by the aggressor China.

noname
06-23-2007, 01:13 PM
Well the Chinese even planned/thought of invading Hong Kong 3 times during the Cultural Revolution, PLA soldiers were over the border and were ready for it (from a recent news report from TVB Pearl). I guess the UK made a good move by handing over Hong Kong "back" to China, to prevent future confrontations.

Anyways it would be very hard to defend Hong Kong (if the brits were still here) if it was attacked by China today, imagine PLA troops parachuting in thousands, en-massing armor and blockading Hong Kong's waters with it's submarines! This would be like Falklands, but Falklands located in arms reach by the aggressor China.

Yeah well of course, but Hong Kong would lie in ruins and so much for the vaunted prize.

hughdotoh
06-23-2007, 01:27 PM
To think that the Chinese lost the Opium War only to hand over a malarial rock to the quai loh!

But hey, if all of China were like Hong Kong, wouldn't it be a better place?

Eusebius
06-23-2007, 02:36 PM
Yeah well of course, but Hong Kong would lie in ruins and so much for the vaunted prize.

Less of a matter to the PRC than anyone can imagine.

Retaking of the islands such as Hong Kong and Taiwan were of political not economical importance.

To retake with force, though is a last resort and might destroy the prosperity of the target, is not a major issue, retaking them intact is merely a bonus.

Kilgor
06-23-2007, 09:35 PM
The chinese were smart enough not to interfere with the system too much, the system that made HK wealthy in the first place.

It did look meanacing when the handover took place, thousands of armed PLA troops rolled in on the back of trucks.