PDA

View Full Version : Archives:Japan asked US prepare for nuclear strike on China



Afro-European
12-23-2008, 05:06 AM
by Staff Writers
Tokyo (AFP) Dec 22, 2008
Japan asked the United States in 1965 to be ready to attack China with nuclear weapons if the two Asian powers went to war, newly declassified documents said Monday.

Japan, the only nation to have suffered atomic attack, has long campaigned to abolish nuclear weapons -- principles that led former prime minister Eisaku Sato to win the Nobel Peace Prize in 1974.
But the foreign ministry declassified documents showing Sato sought a US nuclear strike on China in the event of a war between the two countries.
According to the diplomatic papers, Sato told then US defence secretary Robert McNamara at a 1965 meeting in Washington: "We expect the United States to retaliate immediately using nuclear weapons" in a war.
McNamara, best known as an architect of the Vietnam War, was quoted as replying only that the United States had the technical capability to deploy nuclear weapons overseas.
Sato also said that he would let the United States use Japanese waters, although not its territory, to transport nuclear weapons in the event of a war between Japan and China.
China, then a year away from launching its "Cultural Revolution," was a major cause of concern in the 1960s for World War II rival Japan. Neither Japan or the United States had diplomatic ties with communist China until the 1970s.
Asked Monday about Sato's remarks, Chief Cabinet Secretary Takeo Kawamura, the Japanese government's spokesman, defended the then premier by noting that China had just carried out nuclear tests.
"We can reach a conclusion that no nuclear weapons have been brought to Japan," Kawamura, a member of Sato's long-dominant Liberal Democratic Party, told a news conference.
Sato's three-point non-nuclear policy -- that Japan will not produce, possess or allow the entry of nuclear weapons -- is "determined and steadfast," Kawamura said.
"Washington has understood this," he said.
Sato led Japan from 1964 to 1972, making him the country's longest-serving prime minister.
The United States dropped atom bombs in 1945 on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, killing more than 210,000 people. But the United States is now the main ally of officially pacifist Japan and stations more than 40,000 troops on its soil

http://www.spacewar.com/reports/Japan_asked_US_prepare_for_nuclear_strike_on_China_archives_999.html

Battlebuds
12-27-2008, 10:20 PM
Thanks for posting

Gerry301
12-27-2008, 11:46 PM
http://www.spacewar.com/reports/Japan_asked_US_prepare_for_nuclear_strike_on_China_archives_999.html


Thanks for posting


Just for the record, the number of POWs who died under Japanese control was more than twice the number of Japanese civilians who died during the period. Over 450,000 POWs, mostly chinese, but includes over 12,000 american POWs as well.

The number of Japanese civilians listed as being killed by the Atomic bombs is around 143,000. Most of the other civilians were killed during the firebomb attacks.

This is in contrast to a (lowest estimate) of 10,000,000 Chinese civilians being killed alone.

Just a memo for record.:roll:

domokun
12-28-2008, 01:31 AM
Just for the record. At the time communist China was state with nuclear armament, Japan was and still is non-nuclear country with alliance to USA, that basically protects it's allies with own nuclear deterrence. No first strike policy with nuclear weapons by basically all nuclear armed states is matter of different debate, but in short both Americans and Soviets planned to use nukes from day 1, hour 1 in major conflict. PRC at mid sixties didn't have capability attack Japan in any other way than by bombers, most likely with nuclear payload.

Afro-European
12-28-2008, 06:29 AM
PRC at mid sixties didn't have capability attack Japan in any other way than by bombers, most likely with nuclear payload.
How exactly? China's first nuclear test took place in late 1964 and their first nukes were deployed (according to US intel) in the late 60's,early 70's?

domokun
12-28-2008, 09:53 PM
How exactly? China's first nuclear test took place in late 1964 and their first nukes were deployed (according to US intel) in the late 60's,early 70's?

Did Japan at that time know that China did have only "marginal" nuclear capability? That is matter of speculation. Pakistan's or India's nuclear capability existed quite much before their tests in 1998. Pakistan apparently already had nukes back in mid 80's, according to documentary on TV while back and India had carried "peaceful" test in 1974.

Prime minister Sato's request is still quite hypocritical considering Japans own nuclear weapons policy.

G-AWZT
12-29-2008, 01:02 AM
The Soviets approached us in '71 asking if we wouldn't mind the Soviet Union launching a pre-emptive nuke strike against China. We said yes we would mind.