PDA

View Full Version : Israel to free prisoners for videotape of soldier



Snoshi
09-30-2009, 11:37 AM
JERUSALEM – Israel will release 20 Palestinian women from prison this week in exchange for a videotape proving that an Israeli soldier held in the Gaza Strip is still alive, Israel and Hamas announced Wednesday, in the first tangible sign of movement in more than three years of talks over the captive soldier's fate.

Sgt. Gilad Schalit, a tank crewman seized by Hamas-linked militants in a cross-border raid in June 2006, has not been seen since his capture.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office and Hamas militants in the Gaza Strip said Schalit's captors would release a recent videotape of the soldier in return for the freed prisoners. The swap is to take place on Friday.

The statement from Netanyahu's office said a forum of senior Israeli Cabinet ministers approved the deal, suggested by Egyptian and German mediators, as a "confidence-building measure." It quoted a senior official in Netanyahu's office as saying the negotiations are still "expected to be long and difficult."

Schalit's release would defuse a central point of contention and could help ease a crippling Israeli blockade on the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip.

The deal was to be carried out, the statement said, "ahead of the decisive stages in the negotiations for the release of Gilad Schalit and based on the Israeli government's commitment to work with determination to bring him home quickly."

Hamas is demanding that Israel release hundreds of prisoners, many of whom are serving lengthy sentences for violent attacks on Israelis, in exchange for the soldier. Israel has balked at many of Hamas' demands.

In Gaza, Hamas spokesman Osama Muzini confirmed the deal, which he said was struck after German mediators asked for information on Schalit's health and Hamas responded that "nothing is free."

"Twenty prisoners will be released in exchange for the Zionist enemy's learning about his life through a cassette that shows him and reassures the enemy that he is still alive," Muzini said.

A Hamas Web site reported that the videotape was about one minute long. Israeli officials said the tape would include proof that it had been taken recently. They did not elaborate, but those indications could include footage of a recent newspaper or a verbal mention of a recent event.

A spokesman for Hamas' armed wing using the pseudonym Abu Obeida said the released prisoners would come from various Palestinian factions, including Hamas, the rival Fatah movement and Islamic Jihad. He said one was from Gaza while the rest were from the Fatah-controlled West Bank.

"This simple deal is a precursor, God willing, to a comprehensive deal," he said.

Israel says that while the women were jailed for security-related offenses, they were not directly involved in killing Israelis and are all within two years of the end of their prison sentences. Their names were to be published Wednesday, allowing a legally mandated 48-hour period for court appeals against their release before the deal is carried out.

A senior Egyptian official involved in the mediation said the move was designed to create "an atmosphere of trust."

"There is no doubt that this step will support the efforts of all sides to solve the problem," he said, speaking on condition of anonymity under security guidelines.

Egypt has been trying to mediate a prisoner swap since Hamas-linked militants tunneled into Israel in June 2006 and attacked an Israeli tank, killing two crewmen and capturing Schalit.

The Israeli soldier has not been seen since his capture and the Red Cross has not been allowed to visit him. But several letters and an audio recording have been released by his captors.

Netanyahu approved the deal because he believes it is important that the world know Schalit is alive and well and that his safety is Hamas' responsibility, according to the statement from his office.

Both Hamas and Israel appear eager to wrap up a deal.

For Israel, the return of Schalit would end a painful chapter. In a country where military service is mandatory, Israelis have rallied behind the soldier and his family, holding protests calling for his release and decorating their cars with bumper stickers bearing his name. One news anchor even ends his broadcast each night by mentioning how long Schalit has been in captivity.

Hamas, meanwhile, wants to end an Israeli and Egyptian economic blockade of Gaza that has caused widespread shortages of many basic items. These shortages have prevented Hamas from repairing the massive damage caused in Gaza by an Israeli military offensive last winter.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090930/ap_on_re_mi_ea/ml_israel_palestinians

dracon49
09-30-2009, 12:15 PM
Why to do it?...the German mediator said that he saw the video and he is alive. There is no reason to release 20 terrorists for something we know.

tanks_alot
09-30-2009, 12:22 PM
Why to do it?...the German mediator said that he saw the video and he is alive. There is not reason to release 20 terrorists for something we know.

Could be the first stage of an exchange deal, but i'm also certian the intel community would very much like to see the video and get whatever information possible out of it, even though the most vital things would not be relevant by the time they'll see the video.

rgjbloke
09-30-2009, 12:23 PM
Any move forward, even a tiny one like this, is an encouraging sign that may give just a glimmer of hope, that the two sides can talk to each other. Who knows where that could lead to in the future?

GB_FXST
09-30-2009, 12:31 PM
Why to do it?...the German mediator said that he saw the video and he is alive. There is no reason to release 20 terrorists for something we know.

I suspect that the agreement to release 20 terrorists was part of the deal that allowed the German mediator to even see Gilad. That is, there are trust building steps, starting with the mediator’s visit, and culminating in the release of the terrorists and the video of Gilad.

Isaac Kasabian
09-30-2009, 12:34 PM
Huge mistake in my opinion, negotiating with terrorist and in this case a exchange deal is going to give hamas and other terror groups more incentive to wage in more terror attacks.

I know it's absolute horror for Soldier Gilad Shalit and his family, but if this goes trough, Israel is just given incentive that is fine to kidnapped soldiers because in the end it will negotiate and accept part if not all of their demands.

dracon49
09-30-2009, 12:34 PM
Any move forward, even a tiny one like this, is an encouraging sign that may give just a glimmer of hope, that the two sides can talk to each other. Who knows where that could lead to in the future?
We got if i remember well a videotape of Ron Arad when he was alive and it didnt help(because he is dead now), so i wouldnt be happy even if know that now Gilad is alive, because in the next day it can be that he will be dead.

NimDod
09-30-2009, 05:47 PM
We got if i remember well a videotape of Ron Arad when he was alive and it didnt help(because he is dead now), so i wouldnt be happy even if know that now Gilad is alive, because in the next day it can be that he will be dead.

Back when the Ron Arad tape was aired, he was still alive and they could exchange him for much less than they are asking for Shalit now.

I think this exchange is for the Israeli public opinion - to get the public ready to pay the real price for his release.

Personally, I think they should have made it not worthwhile for the Hamas / other terror organizations to capture Israelies back when he was abducted. If they went on a 'Cast Lead' operation back then instaed of 3 years later, we could have gotten him home, in a much lower price, for both sides.