Bodies of gunmen in Mumbai attacks remain unburied

[JBH22]

By Prachi Pinglay
BBC News, Mumbai
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/999999.gif

http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/45252000/jpg/_45252346_soldier_afp226b.jpg
Troops battled for three days to regain control of Mumbai in November 2008


The bodies of nine gunmen killed during attacks on the Indian city of Mumbai a year ago are still awaiting burial.
The unclaimed bodies are lying in a local government hospital and Mumbai police say they have still to take a decision about their future.
Muslim clerics had denied permission to bury the bodies in Mumbai graveyards, saying the actions of the gunmen had "defamed" their religion.
Ten men attacked Mumbai on 26 November 2008, killing more than 170 people.
Only one gunman, Mohammed Ajmal Amir Qasab, survived and he is currently facing trial.
'Un-Islamic'
The bodies are being kept in the morgue of Sir JJ Hospital. Officials say the area is secluded and guarded around the clock. The seal is checked every day.

http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/shared/img/o.gifTEN NAMED GUNMEN
http://newsimg.bbc.co.uk/media/images/45282000/jpg/_45282928_name226.jpg
Nasir, alias Abu Umar (Nariman House)
Abu Ali (Taj Palace)
Soheb (Taj Palace)
Fahad Ullah (Oberoi)
Mohammed Ajmal Amir Qasab(survived)
Bada Abdul Rehaman (above left, Taj Palace)
Abdul Rehaman Chota (above right, Oberoi)
Ismal Khan (CST station)
Babar Imaran (Nariman House)
Nazir, alias Abu Omer (Taj Palace)


The question of what should be done with the dead militants arose soon after the attacks.
Pakistan flatly refused to take them despite India's argument that they should go back to the country from which they originated.
After post-mortem examinations the bodies were taken to the hospital morgue as Indian Muslims said they would not allow the bodies to be buried in their cemeteries.
Ibrahim Tai, president of the Muslim Council Trust, says he opposes such burials as the gunmen's actions were un-Islamic.
He says if the bodies have to be buried, it should be at "an unknown location".
"We know Indian authorities are stuck as the bodies have not been claimed by Pakistan. These nine people should not be identified by anyone. If they are buried without leaving any trace, then it is fine with us.
"We believe that their actions should not be praised or recognised by anyone. If they set up tombs then tourists will visit and people will talk about it. We don't want that to happen," he said.
Local Muslim cleric Maulana Mustaqil Azmi said it was important that the bodies were disposed of soon and that the matter was closed.
"We do not want them to be buried on any of our burial grounds but they can be disposed of anywhere else in India. Good Muslims are laid to rest in our burial grounds. We do not believe that these nine men are true followers of Islam."
Police say the bodies have been embalmed and are well preserved but a decision on burial has yet to be taken given the religious sensitivity.

IMO India should follow Russia on the way of disposing terrorist corpses..

[Muzungu]

sent them back to the land of pure!

anyway whats the russian way?

[Astaran]

sent them back to the land of pure!

anyway whats the russian way?

Feed them to some pigs p-)

[Divine]

Bury them with pig skin wrapped around. That should teach them a after life lesson :|

[Jµµso]

Fill them with bacon before burying them.

[Migman]

IMO India should follow Russia on the way of disposing terrorist corpses..

Yeah seriously, what is this Russian way you speak of?

[JBH22]

Yeah seriously, what is this Russian way you speak of?

Bury em with pig skins terrorist deserve only such treatment

[budgie]

Congrts on the balanced reports. I'll try not to slip on your **** on the way out

[hulaku]

Congrts on the balanced reports. I'll try not to slip on your **** on the way out

Whaaaat???

[LineDoggie]

Congrts on the balanced reports. I'll try not to slip on your **** on the way out
If you werent the pivot you wouldnt be slathered in it. :)

[Marmot1]

Just dump into sewer system.

[Darklord]

Why can't they just follow the normal procedure for any unclaimed body? Bury them in a BMC graveyard, perhaps.

What a waste of resources otherwise. Guards, mortuary facilities, etc.

[Jobu]

Muslim clerics had denied permission to bury the bodies in Mumbai graveyards, saying the actions of the gunmen had "defamed" their religion.

Well done. We need more of this kind of thing from Muslim clerics in other parts of the world.

[Muzungu]

cremate the damn bodies, the Hindu way!

India have to shed its 'soft' image in dealing with live or dead terrorists!

[Connaught Ranger]

Any rubbish tips nearby?

[hulaku]

Cut into little pieces, cooked in pig fat and Old Monk Rum and fed to the stray dogs in Mumbai.

I offer my services to do the same.

[Military-G]

Go shark fishing?

[Darklord]

Well done. We need more of this kind of thing from Muslim clerics in other parts of the world.

Probably mothers like these too.


‘‘If he has worked against our country, he should get the punishment. For me, the nation is more precious than my son... No mother should face this fate,” said Safia, sitting in her home in Kannur’s Maithanappally.

Safia is the mother of Mohammed Fayaz, 24, one of four from Kerala killed in north Kashmir while trying to cross the Line of Control.

“I don’t want to see his body. The police have told me they would let me know the time of funeral, that’s enough,” she said.
Indian Express (http://www.indianexpress.com/news/son-killed-trying-to-cross-the-loc-she-says-my-country-is-far-more-precious/378360/2)

[California Joe]

Congrts on the balanced reports. I'll try not to slip on your **** on the way out


If you werent the pivot you wouldnt be slathered in it. :)

"Lucky" Pierre.


Well done. We need more of this kind of thing from Muslim clerics in other parts of the world.

Yup. Damn I forgot to watch the HBO Documentary on the Mumbai attack last night.

[Infanteer Two Seven]

Probably mothers like these too.

Indian Express (http://www.indianexpress.com/news/son-killed-trying-to-cross-the-loc-she-says-my-country-is-far-more-precious/378360/2)

why would a guy from Kerala join hands with Pakistani's make no sense.
and good on the mom!!!

Dravidian Pride :P wootwoot

[hulaku]

why would a guy from Kerala join hands with Pakistani's make no sense.


Are you really that naive?

[Muzungu]

why would a guy from Kerala join hands with Pakistani's make no sense.
and good on the mom!!!

Dravidian Pride :P wootwoot

its called 'middle east gulf syndrom effect'!

radicallisation of youth from kerala who work in middle east, takes place there and are sent to carry out jihad againt infidel india!

[Muzungu]

Cut into little pieces, cooked in pig fat and Old Monk Rum and fed to the stray dogs in Mumbai.

I offer my services to do the same.

oh hell ya, let them have the taste of Old Monk!

[Infanteer Two Seven]

Are you really that naive?

I wasn't being sarcastic it was a serious question. but thanks for your answer


its called 'middle east gulf syndrom effect'!

radicallisation of youth from kerala who work in middle east, takes place there and are sent to carry out jihad againt infidel india!

thanks didn't know that... appreciate it.

[Flounder]

Put them in a large cardboard box, label it with a non-existing mailing address and return address, attach insufficient postage, pop it into the nearest mailbox and let the post office deal with it. Problem solved.

[Darklord]

its called 'middle east gulf syndrom effect'!

radicallisation of youth from kerala who work in middle east, takes place there and are sent to carry out jihad againt infidel india!

Buddy, do you have any idea how many mallu youths are there in the ME? If the reason was what you mentioned, Kerala would have been a mini-Afghanistan by now. From what I recall, all those four mallu guys who were killed in Kashmir had a criminal background. Those guys havn't traveled outside India.

[Dolph BG]

Humiliation for them will be to be wrapt in pig skin and buried in the desert,so no one will know their names.This way they will not go in "heaven" with the virgins........

[gaijinsamurai]

Cut into little pieces, cooked in pig fat and Old Monk Rum and fed to the stray dogs in Mumbai.

I offer my services to do the same.

Great idea.

[Laworkerbee]

Yup. Damn I forgot to watch the HBO Documentary on the Mumbai attack last night.

**** me too!

Thank goodness for on-demand.

[Clockwinder]

What would the Russians do? Put 'em through a mulching machine and spread them on the hotel shrubs as fertilizer.

[3rdMillhouse]

Muslim clerics had denied permission to bury the bodies in Mumbai graveyards, saying the actions of the gunmen had "defamed" their religion.

God bless them for their courage to speak up against terrorism.

[dredger14]

God bless them for their courage to speak up against terrorism.

They were pissed off more by the fact that the pakis tried to pan the blame onto the Indian Muslims by calling themselves Deccan Mujahideen. Outraged by this, they have distanced themselves from the terrorists by refusing to bury their bodies.

http://www.youtube.com/v/4n_CLsozSDw

[bono]

Does anyone know why Pakistan will not take them back? By now I am sure its well established these scum were from Pakistan. I would give them the Lenin treatment, put them on public display, and charge a fee to recover cost of rebuilding Mumbai.

[dredger14]

Does anyone know why Pakistan will not take them back? By now I am sure its well established these scum were from Pakistan. I would give them the Lenin treatment, put them on public display, and charge a fee to recover cost of rebuilding Mumbai.

The official government line as far as the local masses are concerned is that it was a joint op carried out by RAW, Mossad and CIA agents, who collaborated to ruin Pakistan's international standing.

Most Pakistanis believe that the surviving terrorist is a Hindu Nepali Hindutva agent.

[Infanteer Two Seven]

Does anyone know why Pakistan will not take them back? By now I am sure its well established these scum were from Pakistan. I would give them the Lenin treatment, put them on public display, and charge a fee to recover cost of rebuilding Mumbai.

world politics is not easy as that.
btw who are you going to charge ? w.e you are smoking thats some good ****.

[pg_ord]

Does anyone know why Pakistan will not take them back? By now I am sure its well established these scum were from Pakistan. I would give them the Lenin treatment, put them on public display, and charge a fee to recover cost of rebuilding Mumbai.
They were "non-state" actors using "non-state explosives" and "non-state weapons".......Pakistan is not involved in state sponsored terrorism. p-)
..... but seriously..... how is it in Pakistan's interest to agree to this? what will anybody do to them if they don't take the bodies back? :roll:

[bono]

Put up on display for paying public. I prefer the 50-50 blend of soot and carbon monooxide fresh from exhausts.


world politics is not easy as that.
btw who are you going to charge ? w.e you are smoking thats some good ****.

[rgjbloke]

It was a heinious crime that these men committed and they don't deserve any memorial of any kind whatsoever, but, they are dead. Just go and bury them somewhere, even in secrecy if you want.

[annihilation]

Why is this a big deal? Dump them in a landfill or burn them to dust. Enough said. They committed a terrorist act, even if the pakis wanted to get the bodies back, I wouldn't give them back. They don't deserve a humane burial.

[Muzungu]

Indian authorities are in a fix for india being a secular country and any kind of un islamic disposal of dead bodies will raise the question of secular india mistreating its minorities!

so thats how 'soft' India is these days!

roflroflrofl

[Ayub -al -Somal]

Just unbelievable !

[WingCommander]

I say toss them over the border...evil scum don't deserve to be buried under Indian soil.


Cut into little pieces, cooked in pig fat and Old Monk Rum and fed to the stray dogs in Mumbai.

I offer my services to do the same.

Why should the dogs eat rotten meat ? p-)


Humiliation for them will be to be wrapt in pig skin and buried in the desert,so no one will know their names.This way they will not go in "heaven" with the virgins........

They aren't going to heaven in any case.

[hulaku]

Just unbelievable !

Can you try and elaborate what you mean?

[Ayub -al -Somal]

Yeah sure

Cut into little pieces, cooked in pig fat and Old Monk Rum and fed to the stray dogs in Mumbai.

I offer my services to do the same.
unbelievable !

[Ritual]

I wonder how they'd taste dried like beef jerky and peppered, I mean you know, just the muscle.

That's ok to eat, right?

[consl]

Well there are no more virgins left in the "heaven" with so many people blowing themselves up so these 9 pakis will have to wait for a while .. I would recommend our Govt. to throw them in the sea so at least some virgin sharks can have some feast ( at least some body would be grateful of pakistanis )

[Infanteer Two Seven]

Yeah sure

unbelievable !

cry me a river.....


I wonder how they'd taste dried like beef jerky and peppered, I mean you know, just the muscle.

That's ok to eat, right?

only in Russia p-)

[Ayub -al -Somal]

Why should I cry about indians talking about wanting to cook up other indians ?
It just unbelievable to me rofl

[hulaku]

Why should I cry about indians talking about wanting to cook up other indians ?
It just unbelievable to me rofl

They were Islamist pigs from across the border in Pakistan, Ummah apologist. Go and hawk your conspiracy theories somewhere else.

[dredger14]

Why should I cry about indians talking about wanting to cook up other indians ?
It just unbelievable to me rofl

Sure Ayub! It was them cunning Yindus collaborating with the Yahudis to defame the pious people of Pakistan.

[pg_ord]

Why should I cry about indians talking about wanting to cook up other indians ?
It just unbelievable to me rofl
TROLL!!!!! ..... facts have been established, you still livin in cuckooland? Anyhow which is better Afghani or Peshawari?p-)

[Eztyga]

I don't think desecration of their corpes is the answer. A common unmarked grave should suffice, or cremation.

[Muzungu]

Yeah sure

unbelievable !

unbelievable!! where was this guy when these 9 pigs were gunning down innocent people in mumbai?

[CanadianStormtrooper]

Incinerate them ffs

[ggk]

burial are fardu kifayah. Even if he is evil, he will be judge by God. But nevertherless a muslim must have a proper burial. Its a sin to let the body just like that.

[junglejim]

burial are fardu kifayah. Even if he is evil, he will be judge by God. But nevertherless a muslim must have a proper burial. Its a sin to let the body just like that.


Come on man, what were they expecting a proper burial, from the Indians?

[JBH22]

Why should I cry about indians talking about wanting to cook up other indians ?
It just unbelievable to me rofl

Because India can kick your butt :bash:

[hulaku]

burial are fardu kifayah. Even if he is evil, he will be judge by God. But nevertherless a muslim must have a proper burial. Its a sin to let the body just like that.

Tell that to the Indian Muslim clerics who are refusing to let them to be buried.

I assume you know that around 60 Muslims also died in the Mumbai attacks.

[dredger14]

burial are fardu kifayah. Even if he is evil, he will be judge by God. But nevertherless a muslim must have a proper burial. Its a sin to let the body just like that.

1. Not everyone believes that
2. The sins committed by those pigs when alive >>>> sin of not burying them.
3. No Indian Muslim wants to pollute their cemetery by burying mass murdering terrorists alongside deceased friends and relatives, otherwise other Muslims will stop using that cemetery.
4. Maybe Malaysia or some other Islamic nation can except the bodies and bury them accordingly, since for them the unburied bodies are more sinful than the deeds committed by the persons when alive.

[CanadianStormtrooper]

4. Maybe Malaysia or some other Islamic nation can except the bodies and bury them accordingly, since for them the unburied bodies are more sinful than the deeds committed by the persons when alive.



You kill someone in that fashion, you might as well go suck your ****.
While watching the Mumbai live coverage, I was sickened.

Negative

[dredger14]

You kill someone in that fashion, you might as well go suck your ****.
While watching the Mumbai live coverage, I was sickened.

Negative

Who killed whom, you were shocked by what?? The NSG killing the terrorists??

[Niels]

Let's fantasize some more about how we can mutilate the bodies using pigs and how that will teach them a lesson when the invisible man upstairs confronts them with it.

[hulaku]

Let's fantasize some more about how we can mutilate the bodies using pigs and how that will teach them a lesson when the invisible man upstairs confronts them with it.

Lets try the BrickTop method.

[dredger14]

http://www.youtube.com/v/4HAQ3pNHwj4

[ggk]

1. Not everyone believes that
2. The sins committed by those pigs when alive >>>> sin of not burying them.
3. No Indian Muslim wants to pollute their cemetery by burying mass murdering terrorists alongside deceased friends and relatives, otherwise other Muslims will stop using that cemetery.
4. Maybe Malaysia or some other Islamic nation can except the bodies and bury them accordingly, since for them the unburied bodies are more sinful than the deeds committed by the persons when alive.

oh man its not the Indian muslim fault...the responsibilities fell to the families...they are the one who are sinned for not preparing a proper burial. In islam, a body (dead body) is the properties of God, must be returned to God properly as we only borrows it for our time in this world.

as for the sin of the terrorist like i said before he will be judged by god after he leaves the body (by dieing lol).

[sujithkochi]

now i understand why malaysia wanted TOP's body to be returned

[hulaku]

as for the sin of the terrorist like i said before he will be judged by god after he leaves the body (by dieing lol).

I guess we could do away with the Justice system cause everybody will be "judged by God" and let the criminals run free happy in our delusions that a figment of human imagination ie God will take care of it.

[ggk]

I guess we could do away with the Justice system cause everybody will be "judged by God" and let the criminals run free happy in our delusions that a figment of human imagination ie God will take care of it.

its because he is dead. If he is still alive we judge him accordingly. Since he is dead, this matter is in the judgement of God.

and we deeply believe the swift retribution of God. Its hard to argue this with an atheist or those who are non muslims, but we believe God judgement in the afterlife are extremely harsh to those who are sinned. No delusional matter as it is our belief.

That said this doesnt stop people being evil though, but we can always flogged them 100 times or beheaded criminal, murderers and rapist and terrorist in public as a preventive measure....but thats just draconian.

[hulaku]

and we deeply believe the swift retribution of God. Its hard to argue this with an atheist or those who are non muslims, but we believe God judgement in the afterlife are extremely harsh to those who are sinned. No delusional matter as it is our belief.


Whatever rocks your boat.

Again on the topic of disposal of their bodies maybe we can get some human flesh eating Aghoris working on them


The Aghoris distinguish themselves from other Hindu sects and priests by their alcoholic and cannibalistic (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannibal) rituals (see necro-cannibalism (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cannibalism#Reasons_for_cannibalism)). The corpses, which may be either pulled from a river [including Ganges] or obtained from cremation grounds, are consumed both raw and cooked on open flame, as the Aghoris believe that what others consider a "dead man" is, in fact, nothing but a natural matter devoid of the life force it once contained. Therefore while for ordinary folks cannibalism may be seen as primitive, barbaric as well as unclean, for aghoris it is being both resourceful and subverting the common stereotypes placed on such taboos into a spiritual ascertainment that indeed nothing is profane nor separate from God, who is hailed to be all and in all. In fact, the Aghoris see it as a scientific approach in trying to discover how matter converts from one form to another.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aghori

[junglejim]

its because he is dead. If he is still alive we judge him accordingly. Since he is dead, this matter is in the judgement of God.

and we deeply believe the swift retribution of God. Its hard to argue this with an atheist or those who are non muslims, but we believe God judgement in the afterlife are extremely harsh to those who are sinned. No delusional matter as it is our belief.

That said this doesnt stop people being evil though, but we can always flogged them 100 times or beheaded criminal, murderers and rapist and terrorist in public as a preventive measure....but thats just draconian.


I see your point in religious belief, but since they did it in Indian land, then those bodies are Indian property. They can do as much as they want with it.

[acosta]

must be a liar.

india paper always says india is the most civilized country in this earth.

[hulaku]

must be a liar.

india paper always says india is the most civilized country in this earth.

What is india paper?

[JBH22]

must be a liar.

india paper always says india is the most civilized country in this earth.

Certainly not the most civilized country on earth but surely more civilized compared to China

[dredger14]

must be a liar.

india paper always says india is the most civilized country in this earth.

Oh but china paper do same!! oh worry!!

What is india paper?
Just like china paper but a tad bit costlier!!

[acosta]

What is india paper?

sorry, papers, such as the widely broadcast "Hulaku Daily"

[acosta]

Oh but china paper do same!! oh worry!!


but is it the truth, india, china, greece were among the earliest civilizations on planet earth?

[JBH22]

sorry, papers, such as the widely broadcast "Hulaku Daily"

LOSERroflrofl

[dredger14]

but is it the truth, india, china, greece were among the earliest civilizations on planet earth?

Well of what use are civilizations when man so easily forgets the wisdom of his elders??

I mean in general, not directed at anyone in particular..

[hulaku]

but is it the truth, india, china, greece were among the earliest civilizations on planet earth?

But India was China's teacherp-)

[JBH22]

But India was China's teacherp-)

Acosta show some gratitudewoot

[acosta]

Acosta show some gratitudewoot

yes, sir, now i am subscriber to the more widely read papers "hulakugfstan times", which printed by hours and more neutralized.

[hulaku]

sorry, papers, such as the widely broadcast "Hulaku Daily"


yes, sir, now i am subscriber to the more widely read papers "hulakugfstan times", which printed by hours and more neutralized.

Thank you dearest comrade acosta. May the Communist party rule for a thousand years and may you one day sit in the Politburo.

Now please go play somewhere else.

Please everybody stay on topic.

[Muzungu]

why some people go green when the word INDIA is mentioned?

roflroflrofl

[acosta]

Cut into little pieces, cooked in pig fat and Old Monk Rum and fed to the stray dogs in Mumbai.

I offer my services to do the same.

what the fvck is this, are you human?

don't tell all indians including your PM think your way!!

[pg_ord]

what the fvck is this, are you human?

don't tell all indians including your PM think your way!!
So asks a bot......:roll:

[sujithkochi]

what the fvck is this, are you human?

don't tell all indians including your PM think your way!!

did u ask the same question when innocents were butchered by these people?

[Muzungu]

did u ask the same question when innocents were butchered by these people?

+1 Sujith

there are many supporters of the land of pure in this forum!