PDA

View Full Version : Learning Arabic - mandatory at schools in pakistan



Muzungu
01-28-2010, 12:03 AM
Thursday, January 28, 2010

The Senate chairman's proposal to make Arabic mandatory at schools is laudable, and its criticism by Shakir Lakhani (January 27) is untenable. Could I ask him if they have ever pondered as to why our politico-religious parties that never let go of an opportunity to agitate in the name of Islam, shariah and Yahood-o-Hunood conspiracy against Islam have never moved a bill in parliament or brought the masses to the streets for making Arabic a compulsory subject for Muslim students in schools? They haven't because they know that by the time a student passed his/her matriculation examination he/she would be able to understand the Quran fairly well. And, a graduate and post-graduate will be able to even interpret it on his/her own. Would the maulvi in that case not lose his papal hegemony over the masses? Can he afford to lose it?

Col (r) Riaz Jafri

Rawalpindi



*****

I disagree with the proposal of making Arabic compulsory at schools. Our academic standards are fairly low. To add yet another subject like Arabic will burden our students who already are showing very poor results. Gen Ziaul Haq made this proposal in one of his cabinet meetings, and he was snubbed by Gen Fazle Haq. That shut up the proposer.

Miangul Aurangzeb

Swat

ggk
01-28-2010, 05:52 AM
Arabic is a hard language to learn... they shouldnt burden the student with that kind of craap...compulsary english are much better IMHO but thats also debatable.

BMUS
01-28-2010, 06:47 AM
Why not Chinese?

Codazo
01-28-2010, 06:53 AM
Nothing wrong with learning lingos!

oldsoak
01-28-2010, 07:28 AM
How much trade does Pakistan do with the Arab world OOI ? In fairness there may actually be a valid commercial reason.

Holycrusader
01-28-2010, 07:48 AM
Arabic is a hard language to learn... they shouldnt burden the student with that kind of craap...compulsary english are much better IMHO but thats also debatable.

English is already widely known in Pakistan. I was there ten years ago and communication was not a problem (in Queta and Lahore at last)...

Five-to-One
01-28-2010, 11:15 AM
Yes, I was there just less than a year ago and was surprised myself at the number of people who could speak english fluently, although because of my circumstances I mostly encountered middle/upper class Pakistanis who already spoke Urdu as their Mother tongue.

I agree though Arabic would just gum up the works, it appears in pakistan there are so many dialects and different languages already in existence they use Urdu to communicate nationally, but then they learn English aswell to communication internationally. For those who don't already speak Urdu at home (majority) forcing Arabic on them would like limit future opportunities

My .02