PDA

View Full Version : Israel's Melting Pot



Ordie
02-22-2010, 03:01 AM
The new faces of Israel

Tel Aviv has become something of a melting pot, with immigrants from the Philippines, Romania and South America.
By Daniella Cheslow
Published: February 21, 2010 09:31 ET
TEL AVIV, Israel — On a Thursday night at Mommy's Place, AJ Masajo took his normal place in front of the karaoke screen. Clutching a microphone, the 34-year-old from the Philippines belted out “Sweet Child of Mine,” including an air guitar solo. Masajo, who studied music in Manila, comes to the restaurant each Thursday.
"It's like the Philippines in here,” said Masajo, dressed in dark jeans and a tight pink shirt. He has worked as a caretaker in Israel for the last four years. “In every home in Manila there's karaoke.”
Mommy's Place is owned by an Israeli-Philippino couple, Yossi and Lucy Hazut, who met 19 years ago. The two-story restaurant is right off Neve Sha'anan, a three-block pedestrian walkway lined with cobblestones and framed by crumbling Bauhaus buildings. The street is the service and cultural center to the city's 40,000 foreign workers and 5,000 African refugees, according to the city of Tel Aviv. On weekends they stream onto the pavement to take a rest from cleaning hospitals, walking the elderly and pounding away on construction sites.
Their increasingly vibrant neighborhood is growing into Israel’s first Chinatown. Yet despite investment from city hall, Neve Sha'anan is also a no-man's land of the homeless, prostitutes and drug addicts of Tel Aviv. Urban planners say that until national Israeli policy accepts the non-Jewish foreigners, their neighborhood will remain marginal.
According to Tel Aviv University Geographer Itzhak Schnell, Israel has had foreign workers since the 1980s. The phenomenon expanded in 1993, when then-Prime Minister Yitzchak Rabin tightly restricted Palestinian day labor in Israel. Foreign workers from Ghana, Thailand, the Philippines and around the world were eager to replace them, and they built their own social outlets.
“The South Americans had salsa clubs and a soccer league, according to nationality,” Schnell said. “The Filipinos had beauty pageants. ... The Romanians went to brothels.”
In a survey he took of neighboring residents, Schnell found Jewish Tel Avivis of all classes open to the foreign workers, whom they saw as quiet and hard-working. Their only reservation was toward the Romanians because of prostitution.
“Part of the reason was that the foreign workers replaced the Palestinians,” Schnell said. “The Israelis thought [the foreign workers] saved us from terrorist attacks.”
Refugees and asylum seekers from Eritrea, Sudan and other African countries began arriving in 2006. Tel Aviv hosts a growing humanitarian infrastructure including a women’s shelter, a clinic and at least 10 African churches.
The openness of Tel Aviv extends to city hall. Ten years ago the city of Tel Aviv founded Mesila, the only municipal welfare organization for foreigners in Israel. Director Tamar Schwartz said the Sudanese did not start businesses right away.
“In the first year or two years, they were in survival mode,” she told GlobalPost. “Then after a year or two, they got jobs, they found apartments. Once their basic needs were met, they began thinking of other needs.”

Sabir Yagoub, 29, started a coffee house a year and a half ago, six months after fleeing Darfur for Israel.
“I walked around Neve Sha'anan and [nearby] Levinsky Park,” Yagoub said. “I saw the people just sitting there on the grass. I thought the people would want a place to hang out."
On a Saturday at 7 p.m., his coffeehouse at Neve Sha'anan 13 was packed with Sudanese and Eritrean men playing cards, sipping on a warm Sudanese milk drink called leben and gazing at an Italian soccer match. One customer was Ibrahim Saadeldin, 29, a Darfurian refugee who used to clean a synagogue in northern Tel Aviv but who is now learning Hebrew five days a week in the hopes of attending law school.
“We live in the tiniest, narrowest rooms,” Saadeldin said. “We come here to breathe. If I need to meet someone, we always decide to meet here.”
While there are Chinese and Ethiopian restaurants elsewhere in Tel Aviv, nowhere in the city or the country are so many non-Jewish foreign businesses clumped together. According to city spokeswoman, Almog Cohen, Neve Sha'anan hosts 90 businesses, mostly eateries and grocery stores. The city does not keep records on the origins of business owners, Cohen said, but Tel Aviv does not require entrepreneurs to be Israeli citizens.
Almog said Tel Aviv has poured “millions” of shekels into renovating Neve Sha'anan, including repaving the street, improving lighting and renovating the large neighborhood Levinksy Park. She said the city and the police cooperate to reduce crime in the area. Yet in January, a Sudanese refugee was shot dead in a clothing store; a week later, an Eritrean was found fatally stabbed outside a Neve Sha'anan restaurant. Men urinate on the streets. In Levinsky Park, heroin users shoot up along the fence of the basketball court.
Israeli Dani Rahon, 42, has sold Asian groceries such as sweet potato noodles and tom yum soup paste for the last seven years. His Dragon store stays open until midnight on weekends, and Rahon said three staff always stay until close because of security. He said he was attacked at night but declined to elaborate.
Schnell cautions that until Israel becomes more accepting of foreigners, Neve Sha'anan will never be a real Chinatown, “a place that's pleasant to walk around in and enjoy the exoticness.”
For two months in the summer, the Ministry of the Interior ruled that all refugees and asylum seekers must live outside Tel Aviv. That measure was rescinded, but in January Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced Israel was building a fence along the Egyptian border to limit infiltrators. Later in the month he announced a plan to reduce the number of foreign workers in Israel, today estimated at 300,000, by at least 10 percent.
“There are periods when the police comes out, and everyone is terrified,” Schnell said. “To create an atmosphere of vibrant communities, its not just to bring a few cleaners [to the area].”
Still, for a few Israelis, Neve Sha'anan is already a place to feel foreign. Last Saturday, Boaz Shamir, 39, and Tamir Noy, 32, picked their way through a sidewalk lined with peddlers hawking vacuum cleaners, clothes, plates and bike racks. They had just come from a Chinese restaurant. Shamir, a lawyer and soundman, said the neighborhood “is not defined as Chinatown. If it was, the city would invest in it. But it is our Chinatown.”
Added Noy, who works in security, “It’s changing the city and I think it’s for the better.”

Source:http://www.globalpost.com/print/5527033

IDF_TANKER
02-22-2010, 04:36 AM
Urban planners say that until national Israeli policy accepts the non-Jewish foreigners, their neighborhood will remain marginal.

Here we go again... This has nothing to do with them being Jewish or not. They are not citizens, they are foreign workers, in many case illegal. Why Israeli national policy should "accept" foreign workers (let alone, illegal ones)? :roll:

Ordie
02-22-2010, 04:41 AM
Why Israeli national policy should "accept" foreign workers (let alone, illegal ones)? :roll:

Probably to fill the jobs that Israelis will not accept.

PsychoDude
02-22-2010, 04:56 AM
The issue is not only to work on these jobs but for less than a minimum

Flamming_Python
02-22-2010, 06:09 AM
Here we go again... This has nothing to do with them being Jewish or not. They are not citizens, they are foreign workers, in many case illegal. Why Israeli national policy should "accept" foreign workers (let alone, illegal ones)? :roll:

You should blame the people that employ them. They themselves are just doing what many in their position would do if given the opportunity.

IDF_TANKER
02-22-2010, 07:55 AM
You should blame the people that employ them. They themselves are just doing what many in their position would do if given the opportunity.

Blaming whoever was not the point of my post. They are people who come here to work - fine by me. I just don't understand the thesis of this article - Israel should absorb the foreign workers into its society? Why?

Kaplanr
02-22-2010, 10:48 AM
Not to mention Neve Sha'anan has been more or less a ****-hole for 60 years.

Hollis
02-22-2010, 11:00 AM
I think this article, one can substitute Israel for the name of any other Western country, or country that has foreign nationals working there. Even the US, had enclaves of immigrants. As a kid in Chicago, we had Polish neighborhoods, Italian ones, German ones, etc. It was not forced on anyone, it naturally occurs as people like being around like people.

squidO
02-22-2010, 01:16 PM
Another article on the same subject:


Israel's immigrant children fight deportation


By Katya Adler
BBC News, Jerusalem


Five little girls giggle and scream with delight as they chase each other round the playground, their pigtails flying as they run.
The girls' parents come from the Philippines, Thailand and Sudan but they sing, shout and chat together in Hebrew.
Like her friends, bright-eyed, eight-year-old Noah Mae was born in Israel. This is her home, she says.
I've come to meet her at a community centre run by the Israeli Scouts movement in southern Tel Aviv.
She proudly shows me her schoolbook, where she got top marks for her Hebrew writing and spelling.
Here parents might come from the Philippines but she feels truly Israeli. Hebrew is the language she dreams in, she tells me.
Pressure groups
But Israel's government now wants Noah Mae to leave. Here it's illegal for migrant workers to have children.
Hundreds of families face expulsion from Israel this summer. More than 1,000 children, including Noah Mae, expect to be deported at the end of their school year.

“ 'Mama,' she said to me, 'I am Israeli. I was born here and I will stay here.' ”
Emily Cabradilla Mother of Noah Mae

Noah May's mother, Emily Cabradilla, together with a number of Israeli pressure groups, is trying to fight the government's plan to include the children in a crackdown on illegal immigrants.
She said it broke her heart when she heard the news. "Noah Mae has never been to the Philippines. How can I tell her she's going home? She hardly speaks a word of Tagalog.
"She says she won't leave Israel. 'Mama,' she said to me, 'I am Israeli. I was born here and I will stay here.'"
But laws in Israel make it extremely hard for people to stay, to become citizens, if they are not Jewish.
Right from its birth, Israel called itself the Jewish State. This is a country built for and built by immigrants from all over the world but with a key common factor - a Jewish heritage.
According to Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, controlling immigration is largely about preserving Israel's Jewish character.
His government intends to deport all illegal immigrants by 2013 and also to drastically reduce the number of legal foreign workers in Israel.
In the face of some public opposition to the government's policy, Israel's Interior Minister and Deputy Prime Minister, Eli Yishai, accused Israelis of being hypocritical and sanctimonious. "Don't they [the foreign workers] threaten the Zionist project of the State of Israel?" he asked.
Mr Yishai caused an outcry in the autumn when he accused migrant workers of bringing with them "a profusion of diseases: hepatitis, measles, tuberculosis, Aids and drug (addiction)".
And the plan to deport the children proved so controversial the government has delayed it from last summer until the end of the 2010 school year.
'Like a stranger'
A new immigration police force - the Oz Unit - now patrols Israel's streets as part of the government crackdown. We accompanied a team of policemen around the old central bus station in southern Tel Aviv.
The teeming, narrow pedestrian alleys here reveal a social world rarely seen in Israel. Here Chinese men sell cigarettes and children's clothes, Sudanese refugees hawk CDs and DVDs while Philippine and Thai women share a joke on a street corner.
Israel increased the number of work permits it issued to South East Asian workers in particular after the start of the second Palestinian uprising.


They've taken the place of Palestinian workers; Israel's government severely restricts their permits and presence in Israel for security reasons, it says.
Everyone here looks uncomfortable as the police approach.
Commander Igal Ben Ami says he doesn't enjoy deporting people who have made friends and have a life here but he says he has to follow orders.
"Look around this part of town," he says, listing to me dozens of nationalities who hang out here, especially at night.
"This is an Israeli street, a Jewish street, but I feel the stranger here."
Mr Netanyahu says Israel will always open its doors to refugees from war-stricken countries but will not let thousands of foreign workers "flood the country".
History of persecution
While his government speaks of the need to expel non-Jewish migrant workers and their children born here, it sponsors organisations that encourage Jewish people from all over the world to move to Israel.

“ Especially in the shadow of the Holocaust, many Jews chose to come and live here ”
Mark Rosenberg Nefesh B'Nefesh

Israel insists this has nothing at all to do with racism. Most here feel having a Jewish state is important considering the Jewish people's long history of persecution.
Mark Rosenberg works for Nefesh B'Nefesh, a group that encourages Jews to move to Israel.
He explains that Israel offers citizenship to anyone with a Jewish grandparent, because under the Nazis anyone with a Jewish grandparent was eligible to be murdered in the gas chambers.
"Especially in the shadow of the Holocaust, many Jews chose to come and live here - 85% of the country is Jewish. The idea is that this nation is a homeland where Jews can be free."
But the children of foreign workers in Israel say they know no other home. Israeli governments used to turn a blind eye but no longer.
'Punished'
Young Israeli campaigner Rotem Ilan heads the Children of Israel organisation.
She says children like Noah Mae are being punished for a crime they didn't commit.
The fact that they were born in Israel is Israel's responsibility, she insists.
It allowed the children's parents to come here.
Her organisation is one of a number of NGOs organising protests against the children's deportation.
"For 20 years Israeli governments have turned a blind eye to these children. They are now part of the fabric of this country. They go to school here. They celebrate the same holidays as us. If there is something we [Jews] have learned from our history is that you must not, you cannot deport children."
Israel's government did not respond to our requests for an interview.
Noah Mae and her friends hope politicians may yet change their minds and let them stay.
And how will she feel if they don't? "Bad," she said sadly. "I love Israel."
------------------------------------------------------------------
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/8524723.stm




For some reason, the author all the time emphasize the Jewish - nonJewish issue. Well, actually I am not surprised, it's BBC after all...

In fact, all this has nothing to do with Jewishness. The key word here, is if a person is legally or illegally stays in the country,.
In Israel, Jews enjoyed a great advantage in obtaining the right to residence and citizenship. But at the same time any person, regardless of ethnic or religious background can apply for immigration.

I think it is a common rule in any country. If a person resides in the country illegally, it is subject to deportation. And in any country there are some preferences.
How would you concider such a claim: "Hey, they want to deport him because he is not a millionare, not a Nobel Prize laureat, and not a sport star. What a terrible discrimination!"
:|

I hope some of the cases described in the article could be solved individually. In Israel there is Jus Sanguinis and not no Jus Soli principle of citizenship. However the kids should not be responsible for their parents, which violated the law. But I am afraid the only general legal solution for these people is to return to the country of their origin, and to apply for immigration to Israel from there.

GB_FXST
02-22-2010, 02:13 PM
I think this article, one can substitute Israel for the name of any other Western country, or country that has foreign nationals working there. Even the US, had enclaves of immigrants. As a kid in Chicago, we had Polish neighborhoods, Italian ones, German ones, etc. It was not forced on anyone, it naturally occurs as people like being around like people.

And, Mexican and Indian and Chinese and Vietnamese and Jewish (Rogers Park native here) ... which is why Chicago is such a fantastic city. I do not miss the Chicago winters, but I miss the wonderful variety of good ethnic food ... :)




... snip ...

For some reason, the author all the time emphasize the Jewish - nonJewish issue. Well, actually I am not surprised, it's BBC after all...

In fact, all this has nothing to do with Jewishness. The key word here, is if a person is legally or illegally stays in the country,.
In Israel, Jews enjoyed a great advantage in obtaining the right to residence and citizenship. But at the same time any person, regardless of ethnic or religious background can apply for immigration.

I think it is a common rule in any country. If a person resides in the country illegally, it is subject to deportation. And in any country there are some preferences.
How would you concider such a claim: "Hey, they want to deport him because he is not a millionare, not a Nobel Prize laureat, and not a sport star. What a terrible discrimination!"
:|

I hope some of the cases described in the article could be solved individually. In Israel there is Jus Sanguinis and not no Jus Soli principle of citizenship. However the kids should not be responsible for their parents, which violated the law. But I am afraid the only general legal solution for these people is to return to the country of their origin, and to apply for immigration to Israel from there.

Lots of countries do not recognize Jus Soli, or only recognize a modified version of Jos Soli, like the BBC's homeland.

At any individual level, I do empathize with the individuals cought in the dilemma of being an illegal resident.

dracon49
02-22-2010, 02:40 PM
Left wingers protest against the decision to expel illegal workers because they want Israel to become a bi-national state.

Havoc345
02-22-2010, 03:39 PM
Personally I feel that Israel has every right to protect their continued existence as a JEWISH STATE. Too often we are caught up in the tired mantras of diversity and multiculturalism to remember that everyone needs a homeland. Now when I say homeland I don't mean one that is 100% ethnically exclusive, but that has a single prevailing ethnic background that identifies that homeland. This is why a people who have never been afforded the right to have a homeland in history deserve Israel.

What people will realize in the 21st century is that this will have to be one nation-building and not immigration. Migrants are stuck in the mentality that because their country is not condusive to a decent lifestyle they should immigrate to another to country to gain a better life and more oppurtunity. But outside of the United States which has a very rigid assimilation model, what has this produced ? Intolerance and misunderstanding, As most immigrants cannot reconcile their third world culture in the first world. Look at Malmo, Amsterdam, London and so on and so forth. Soon in Israel we could radical Muslims setting up shop in immigrant Tel Aviv neighborhoods like the one mentioned above. This is why I feel that Israel is correct in being alarmed by this demographic threat, just as they are correct in being alarmed at the Arab birthrate.

Havoc345
02-22-2010, 03:52 PM
I should also note that for years Palestine has encouraged Arabs to settle in Jerusalem so as to eventually overwhelm the city demographically. Which they have done rather successfully if you take the Orthodox/Haredi birth rate into account.