PDA

View Full Version : Maus



Skaman
07-04-2005, 01:31 AM
http://www.iath.virginia.edu/holocaust/mauscover.gif

I recently finished reading both volumes of Maus, an illustrated narrative detailing the horrors of the holocaust by Art Spiegelman, who in his work interviewed his father Vladek, a survivor of the persecution and genocide. Maus is written in a post modern Orwellian style, reminiscent of Animal Farm, where the author had replaced human participants with animal counterparts, evocative off their human qualities within the animal symbolism. Spiegelman plays with this idea and the notion of animalistic qualities by portraying the victimized Jewish peoples as mice, while the Nazi’s are the Cats. Immediately, Maus has differentiated itself from other contemporary works detailing the holocaust by using the medium of both the graphic novel, and animal symbolism. However, the work is to be appreciated on a much more creative and compelling level than on its artistic flair, as foremost, its narrative style is unusually humanistic and emotional, shedding the cliché and overused Hollywood stereotypes. The book is undeniably moving, offering a rare insight into personal accounts seeing that the story develops around the relationship of Vladek and his son Art, the author of Maus. Spiegelman’s work is disturbing, yet rich, gripping but uncomfortable. The post war relationship dynamics of the family are explored in one arc of the story, while the other is dedicated to the Jewish persecution. Together, these complimentary works create a more comprehensive and fulfilling story that like no other holocaust literature has affected me. Maus is brutally honest, and thoroughly interesting, a fine piece of work that has not received greater credit than it deserves. Pick up a copy of Maus.

weissent
07-04-2005, 01:58 AM
The main flaw of "Maus" is that it depicts nationalities as different species, which was the first step to the Jewish holocaust +another 5mio murdered.

Bulkowski
07-04-2005, 02:02 AM
*Do Do Doo!*
http://www.ket.org/images/nola/RERA__.1037775.200x150.jpg
Wow, Thanks Skaman.

Our next reader is Mike, from Illonois, with his book on a journey with his father to the Vietnam War memorial...
http://images.amazon.com/images/P/0395629772.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

ridenrain
07-04-2005, 02:13 AM
http://www.sfreviews.net/irondream_copy.jpg
If you get a chance, this is a good laugh.
The idea is that an outspoken young guy never goes into politics and instead becomes a science fiction writter.
http://www.sfreviews.net/irondream.html

Onyks
07-04-2005, 02:50 AM
I read those books six years ago, and quite frankly when the author chose to depict Poles as pigs I've never been more furious with such a well-thought out decision to do so.

Rantanplan
07-04-2005, 05:58 AM
Are there any super heroes in this comic. Batman, Lobo or Freakazoid?

Eat a bullet
07-04-2005, 12:37 PM
Are there any super heroes in this comic. Batman, Lobo or Freakazoid?
SUPERMANNN?!
http://img50.imageshack.us/img50/3797/supertard2yv.jpg

Rantanplan
07-04-2005, 12:40 PM
w00t1

mudbunny
07-04-2005, 12:48 PM
I have a caption for your pic Eat a bullet.................

2 years after Supermans unfortunate fall from the top of the Metropolis mental institution, he found himself still lacking in motivation and unable to face the outside world, instead, contempt to merely pass the hours making "mean" faces at his cat and trying to flex the muscles that his body had long forgotten. It had been a sad time in the life of this former superhero. His neighbor had recently called the cops on him for masturbating to pictures of Jean Grey, on his balcony, while wearing nothing but his cape. Sad times indeed.

el borracho
07-04-2005, 01:02 PM
I remember the Americans were dogs (to chase the cats maybe), the French were frogs (yeah, I'm not making that up), and the Brits were fish...I don't know wtf was up with that. The use of animals was a big mistake, because not only did that insult nations (Poland as pigs, French as frogs) but since the Jews, regardless of nationality, were portrayed as mice then it just added fuel to the argument that Jews hold their religious identity in higher regard than their national one.

(Again, not my opinion, just an observation).

Skaman
07-04-2005, 02:30 PM
I remember the Americans were dogs (to chase the cats maybe), the French were frogs (yeah, I'm not making that up), and the Brits were fish...I don't know wtf was up with that. The use of animals was a big mistake, because not only did that insult nations (Poland as pigs, French as frogs) but since the Jews, regardless of nationality, were portrayed as mice then it just added fuel to the argument that Jews hold their religious identity in higher regard than their national one.

(Again, not my opinion, just an observation).


Speigelman addresses this within the book, particular regarding the dilemma of his girlfriend who was born French, and later converted to Judaism. Speigelman created all Jews in the same likeness to circumvent further nationalistic/religious complications which would confuse the reader. Interesting observation though…