PDA

View Full Version : "Andy MacNabb" Interview....read his comments abou



Argyll
02-04-2004, 08:00 AM
Not sure if this has been posted before,I've just come across it,so apologies if it has!
His take on Iraq is pretty interesting


SUNDAY PEOPLE


‘If I’d been born here, I could have joined the IRA’


ALAN HEALY talks to SAS man-turned-author Andy McNab, who served in Derry in the 1980s


Prior to the Iranian Embassy Siege in 1980, very little was known publicly about the SAS, but now, what with ‘Bravo Two Zero,’ and Chris Ryan’s books (not to mention his personal SAS fitness guide recently serialized in The Sun) the SAS has become something of a public commodity. What’s your take on the recent media explosion?
It’s a very strange, bizarre situation because before the Iranian Embassy Siege you did have a lot of books about the regiment but they were only bought by military buffs, whereas now the badge has become commercially viable.
Yes, some former SAS members are very pissed off because people died for that badge and now it’s being abused.
I’m now a director in a security company and the vast majority of guys we take are ex-Regiment but they consciously stay away from this stuff. I’d say 98% of the guys don’t go public on their past due to the nature of the operations they were involved in and wouldn’t want to be associated with it anyway.

How do you feel about the fact that people who don’t normally read literature seem to have read Bravo Two Zero at some point?
A recent survey showed that Bravo Two Zero alongside Harry Potter - was one of the most popular books being read by schoolchildren. When asked about the violence in the books the teachers said they didn’t mind as long as they were reading!
In the books, in many instances the Stone character is trying to run away and I hope that this realism gives readers an exposure to the fact it’s not all heroics.

How do you feel about the SAS’s involvement in the Northern Ireland conflict, particularly in relation to controversial killings carried out by the unit in the early to mid eighties?
Well, if you go back to Ancient Greece you’ll find that every conflict necessitated the use of special forces, covert forces or whatever you want to call them and we were just part of that war alongside other groups like Special Branch.
And as far as this business of a “shoot-to-kill” policy, it simply didn’t exist because there would have been a lot more people dead.
And a lot of people don’t know that the SAS were actually offered immunity by a government at the time for any work we carried out. We refused because we knew that the next year it would have been lifted.
And yes I was in Derry for quite a while- I worked in the Bogside, Shantallow and Creggan as part of the SAS and later in 14 INT where the bulk of our work was intelligence gathering.
There’s a lot of misperception about us – we were just walking around and we blended in, the grey man, nondescript. We weren’t like ninjas hiding under floorboards because if that’s the kind of thing that gets noticed.
Look when it comes down to it, if you grow up on housing estate in South London, you join the army, and if I had grown up on a housing estate in Shantallow, I could well have joined PIRA.
We were simply a strategic force and I do think our work in the SAS and 14 INT in Derry and Northern Ireland played a big part in bringing forward the eventual Good Friday Agreement because PIRA were losing lot of intelligence – and a lot of men – to us in the mid to late eighties and early nineties.

Have you returned to Derry since then?
I was in Derry as a ‘civvie’ three years ago doing some Christmas shopping and I had a good walk around and Christ, it’s changed. There seems to have been a lot of investment in the city and it’s great to see, the place is looking really well.

Another book focusing on your exploits in first Gulf War, ‘The Real Bravo Two Zero’ by Michael Asher claimed that you fabricated much of your story in Bravo Two Zero – how did that affect you?
If it had have been five years ago then yeah, I would have really sparked up about it – but I understand the business now, and what many people don’t realize is that there is a huge fraternity of people making money off the back of this book.
Asher wasn’t even in the regiment, so I don’t where he’s coming from a about this but I don know there’s a lot of people growing fat off the back of him and his book.
And funnily enough, sales of Bravo Two Zero actually went up after Asher’s book was released, so it really did me no harm.


Having served in the first Gulf War, how do you view events unfolding now on a daily basis in Iraq, especially in light of many commentators comparing the current situation with Northern Ireland?
I was actually out there a month ago and went on patrol with the Americans - it was mostly just a bunch of very young nervous men still getting zits, many of whom were National Guards and had basically joined the military for the dental plan.
It was very like the situation in Northern Ireland, except the Americans just aren’t equipped – or properly trained - for that kind of role and conflict, while the British Army have this kind of experience in both Northern Ireland and Bosnia.
The situation is bad though - I witnessed soldiers putting their body armour in their Hummer jeeps so they wouldn’t be hit by bullets passing through the doors, so they’re learning the hard way, but at least they’re learning.
Some of those guys are veterans now. They thought they would be only posted for a couple of months but the soldiers that were there for the pre-war build in Saudi have been out there for a year now and most of them just want to get back home.
What I found amazing was that so many American soldiers didn’t realize that Baghdad was fully functioning, sophisticated and grown–up modern city – they thought they were going to be greeted by people living in mud huts. And many of them were like, “What the…?”
While we were out on patrol, they had no interpreter and some of them didn’t really know what they were doing.
I asked them if they knew about the 20-minute rule - part of our standard operating procedure in Northern Ireland to ensure we weren’t in the same spot for too long and presented an easy target, but these guys we’re still hanging around after 45 minutes and I was telling them that they really should be getting out of there!
The Brits wear their berets and take off their sunglasses when engaging with the locals and this has done them a lot of good, meaning that low level intelligence off the street – which often the most important – can be passed all the way back up the line. Whereas the Americans were relying on passing by and listening to the mosques to gauge local opinion.

Your new book, ‘Dark Winter’ focuses on the Al – Qa’ida as the ‘bad guys’ – is it a conscious decision for you to mix reality with fiction when planning your next work?
A lot of people seem to think that Osama Bin Laden is the chairman of the board but what they don’t realize is that Al Qa’ida is actually made up of a lot of fragmented groups such as the Muslim Bortherhood so this isn’t necessarily a new thing – and the U.S had been fighting this war on terrorism a long time before the events of 9/11.
There was a bounty of $25 million being offered for Bin Laden’s head before the public had any idea of who he actually was.


Have you watched Ultimate Force?
(Laughing) No I haven’t, I’ve been in the States.

And whose books are better, yours or Ryan's?
That’s easy – mine!

Royal
02-04-2004, 08:11 AM
Interesting that he slags Asher off (fair enough he was only TA - although he was in the Regiment), but doesn't actually deny that a good chunk of 'Bravo Two Zero' was absolute bollocks.

My thousandth post woot

Vance
02-04-2004, 08:12 AM
Nice comments by McNab. :)

And congrats, Royal! woot

Gringo
02-04-2004, 08:48 AM
I don't like Asher either. There are obviously going to be conflicting reports of what happened from the memebers of the B20 patrol. But I suppose if u were sleep deprived, beaten and tortured u would find it difficult to remember certain details.

Chops
02-04-2004, 08:58 AM
Or manufacture tales of huge firefights against a mechanised infantry platoon??? ;)

rgds

c

Trigger
02-04-2004, 12:53 PM
Great article Argyll!!
Thanks

Yay Royal woot

TriggerPuller
02-04-2004, 02:49 PM
McNabb has no honor same as Eric Haney!!!

TP

Trigger
02-04-2004, 03:13 PM
er, what? :|

TriggerPuller
02-04-2004, 03:21 PM
er, what? :|You got a problem with what I said or genuinely missing the point?

TP

Trigger
02-04-2004, 03:25 PM
Missing the point. Please elaborate.

TriggerPuller
02-04-2004, 03:35 PM
Missing the point. Please elaborate.What 2 similar units were these 2 in? Let me put it another way, what's the first rule about fight club? Now you get it? Haney founding member of Delta my ass,plus there are other discrepencies in his book,that should have never been written! Nuff said!!

TP

martinexsquaddie
02-04-2004, 04:10 PM
apprantly mcnabb got told to piss off by the SAS when he went to Basra :(

ibstolidude
02-04-2004, 04:18 PM
McNabb has no honor same as Eric Haney!!!

TP
Damn!

I posted that your answer to the retarded Delta Patch question was the best slap yet here....until I saw this.

TriggerPuller
02-04-2004, 05:26 PM
apprantly mcnabb got told to piss off by the SAS when he went to Basra :(If true do you blame them?

TP

Royal
02-04-2004, 06:01 PM
apprantly mcnabb got told to piss off by the SAS when he went to Basra :(If true do you blame them?

TP

No.

He's also be f**ked off from Stirling Lines (as has everyone else who's spilled their guts, DLB included).

Roger Rabbit
02-04-2004, 06:54 PM
Royal, do they have the same attitude to Peter Ratcliffe as well?

TriggerPuller
02-04-2004, 07:18 PM
apprantly mcnabb got told to piss off by the SAS when he went to Basra :(If true do you blame them?

TP

No.

He's also be f**ked off from Stirling Lines (as has everyone else who's spilled their guts, DLB included).DLB? Sorry for my ignorance.
I am sure the same with Ryan, I was under the impression he was under some sort of gag order not to write about his SAS exploits from the British Government. There is just too much info on our TS units. I like the British viewpoint, if you are not with the Regiment then you dont need to know about the Regiment! Period!

TP

Chops
02-04-2004, 07:41 PM
TP

DLB= (General) Sir Peter de la Billiere; former boss of 22 and Commander, British Forces Middle East, during GW1. Banned fron Credenhill after publication of two books recounting SF operations. The ban still stands- I hear he was booted out by Director, SF from a function late last year in H. OC 22 was mortfied but the DSF had the final word.

Ryan's name is dirt, just like 'McNab'. Ratcliffe hasn't received the same treatment interestingly but having read his biography with it's debunking of many popular SF myths, it's something the Regiment might well appreciate and thus tolerate. Plus he was the RSM... ;)

rgds, c

PS- off for more fun in a fortnight :| . You in employment?

Andyman
02-04-2004, 08:04 PM
In "the one that got away" Chris Ryan talks about how all th other guys in the unit were fine but he said that Mcnabb hated him due to the failure of the mission or something. Chris said that because he was the leader of the patrol when they got split Mcnabb blamed him for the separation and the deaths of the other men.

Chris Ryan does like video game coordination now or something. He helped make that game IGI (I'm Going In) and IGI2 WOW!!

Nunavut's sewage
02-04-2004, 08:20 PM
I bet an Israeli Cyborg legal drug cartel posted that to fool us!!

TriggerPuller
02-04-2004, 10:31 PM
TP

DLB= (General) Sir Peter de la Billiere; former boss of 22 and Commander, British Forces Middle East, during GW1. Banned fron Credenhill after publication of two books recounting SF operations. The ban still stands- I hear he was booted out by Director, SF from a function late last year in H. OC 22 was mortfied but the DSF had the final word.

Ryan's name is dirt, just like 'McNab'. Ratcliffe hasn't received the same treatment interestingly but having read his biography with it's debunking of many popular SF myths, it's something the Regiment might well appreciate and thus tolerate. Plus he was the RSM... ;)

rgds, c

PS- off for more fun in a fortnight :| . You in employment?Thanks Chops. is your last question for me about employment? Take care

TP

P.S. what the hell is a fortnight? :D

Gordon
02-04-2004, 10:37 PM
fortnight = two weeks.

Take it easy.

Chops
02-04-2004, 11:11 PM
TP

"Last question about employment"? WTF? I was referring whether you were OS soon. Don't get that one mate.

rgds

c

TriggerPuller
02-05-2004, 01:59 PM
fortnight = two weeks.

Take it easy.Thanks G. My English sucks but my American is pretty good!!! :D

TP

Trigger
02-05-2004, 03:21 PM
Question for TP:
Do you believe Charlie Beckwith or **** Marcinko also have 'no honor'?
They too broke the fight club rule.
No disrespect intended, just wondering.

California Joe
02-05-2004, 03:24 PM
I never broke the rule. I have a friend that was in Fight club. Just sayin'.

Argyll
02-05-2004, 03:47 PM
;) But he never talks about it!!?

California Joe
02-05-2004, 03:59 PM
Nah, he does, has a picture with a fake bruise and everything.......Oh wait.....Nope. ;)

OldRecon
02-05-2004, 04:42 PM
Interesting reading.
As for SAS policy towards ex-members spilling the beans - It's purely logical.
Though after the publication of B-2-0 there seemed to be a haemorage of books by ex-reg people (or people claiming to be so).
As for banning ex-members do that go to John Wiseman (author of several SAS "survial manuals") and that G-squadron ex-sergeant who took part in the Mogadishu raid (don't remember his name, but has written several books on SAS-theme). At least he got some publicity in Norway too, with regards to a reunion with the only surviving PLO-fighter (or did she belong to that PFLP group of George Habbash?) from that incident (forgot her name too). She was under trial for acts of terrorism in Norway at the time. She had lived in Norway under false identity for several years before here true identity was discovered (think it had something to do with the fall of the wall and the unraveling of the Stasi archives, but may be wrong here again??).
As for B-2-0 found it quite an interesting book, but to take it all at face value?? :roll:.
The way the troopers on the ground appear to have been taken with surprise by the local climatic conditions (the cold), perhaps go to show that even the best aren't faultless sometimes. At least it can't be said that it showed SAS pre-planning at its best.
As for the reasons behind writing those post gulf-war 1 books, perhaps it became sort of a way for them to counter the possibility of PTSD?? (Given what they went through, I sort of don't blame them. To crack is no sin, though it's important to keep oneself and one's mates in line for as long as possible when in a thight spot for an extended period).
As for countering PTSD we have a former marine jaeger here who made a living out of going on expeditions after he left the service (solo skiing on both poles, Mount Everest and that sort of stuff), who I think more than once have admitted he couldn't take an "ordinary" job.
On the one hand on can't let be feeling somewhat impressed about his achievements, though on the other hand one also feel a bit sorry for him too. Because somehow one feels there's an element off a misfit in him, and that he wouldn't take it out so far if he had been able to settle better "at home".

TriggerPuller
02-05-2004, 04:52 PM
Question for TP:
Do you believe Charlie Beckwith or **** Marcinko also have 'no honor'?
They too broke the fight club rule.
No disrespect intended, just wondering.I really dont want to speak on this anymore but for the sake of sounding like a hypocrite I would say no......well Sharkman is a little questionable!! Maybe the founders get a free pass but I have to think about it a little more.

As for Weismann his books were more geared towrds survival and not Operational stories.He gets a pass.

TP

Argyll
02-05-2004, 04:58 PM
Barry Davies was the Mog man,Lofty Weismann did not divulge any Operational stuff ,and neither did Barry Davies IIRC,they never talked about Ops.....more a historical history....it was guys like Yorky Crossland who claimed to kill the 1st Iraqi during GW1 ,a fact that Radcliffe calls a load of Bollocks!!
Same goes for Cameron Spence....another bad boy!

CX20
02-05-2004, 08:56 PM
In that case Eddie Stone and John MacAleese must be top of the hitlist. I thought some of the stuff on that "SAS Survival Secrets" series was a little too close to home, especially some bits of the CT/CP stuff. I heard one of my bosses commenting on how they gave away the colour coding identification system for buildings, which he said was supposedly restricted.

I read Ratcliffe's book and found it to be fascinating, unbias and honest. One of my colleagues used to work with him and said that he wouldn't have expected anything less than an honest, no-**** account from him.

I hate to admit it, but I've read most of the SAS books (they get passed around and "do the rounds" amongst our team). Ratcliffe's is the only one worth reading, the rest are too infected with ego-inspired BS.

TriggerPuller
02-05-2004, 10:03 PM
[quote="CX20"] I heard one of my bosses commenting on how they gave away the colour coding identification system for buildings, which he said was supposedly restricted. {quote}

One of the Delta/CAG books got into this also,just cant remember which one right now. Not good!!

TP

reverence
02-10-2004, 01:56 AM
If your comms are encrypted it doesnt matter what you are calling which side of the building as no on ecan hear what you're saying anyway. Im not saying the info shoul dhave been released just that it doesn't change the way SF conduct ops. Many countries have slightly different systems anyhow.(i know just the ticket for interoperability.

cold0
02-11-2004, 07:43 AM
He was Eric Haney in Inside the Delta Force that described how they gave away the colour coding identification system for buildings.
The system is the same described by McNab in Istant Action

Maj C
02-11-2004, 08:38 AM
trigger puller - you sound a lot like a certain mgysgt i use to work with in miramar????

lekomin
02-11-2004, 09:26 AM
TP
Ratcliffe hasn't received the same treatment interestingly but having read his biography with it's debunking of many popular SF myths, it's something the Regiment might well appreciate and thus tolerate. Plus he was the RSM... ;)

actually by far this is the best book I've ever read about the Regiment. It is to the point and no Superman bull**** added. I liked the passage where he explains why MacNab and one other bloke (the one that wrote a book called Sabre Squadron, he was a member of the mobile convoy, that Ratcliff took command of) are idiots and liars in what they write. VEEERY GOOD book by Ratcliffee. btw. RSM is the TOP post in the SAS I would say.
take care
lekomin inc