PDA

View Full Version : Lice 'undermined Napoleon's army'



ed316
12-19-2005, 02:06 PM
http://newsvote.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/img/printer_friendly/news_logo.gif
Lice 'undermined Napoleon's army'
Hard genetic evidence that lice-borne disease played a key role in Napoleon's disastrous retreat through Russia in 1812 has been produced by researchers.
Experts analysed dental pulp extracted from the teeth of soldiers who died during the campaign.
They found lice-borne versions of typhus and trench fever ran rampant among the French Grand Army.
The study, by the Université de la Méditerranée in Marseille, is published by the Journal of Infectious Diseases.

Wherever there is warfare there is always infectious disease
Dr Carole Reeves

Napoleon marched into Russia in the summer of 1812 with 500,000 soldiers.
Only a few thousand staggered out again, victims of war, weather, and disease.
Twenty-five thousand arrived in Vilnius that winter, but only 3,000 lived to continue the retreat. The dead were buried in mass graves.
Construction work in 2001 unearthed one such grave, containing between 2,000 and 3,000 corpses.
Bone fragments
Researchers led by Dr Didier Raoult identified body segments of five lice in a forensic excavation of two kilograms of earth containing fragments of bone and remnants of clothing.
Three of the lice carried DNA from Bartonella quintana, which causes the disease commonly known as trench fever and afflicted many soldiers in World War I.
The team analyzed dental pulp from 72 teeth, taken from the remains of 35 soldiers.
Dental pulp from seven soldiers contained DNA from B. quintana, and pulp from three soldiers contained DNA from Rickettsia prowazakii, which causes epidemic typhus.
In all, 29% of the soldiers tested had evidence of either R. prowazkii or B. quintana infection.

Wherever there is warfare there is always infectious disease
Dr Carole Reeves
Medical historian

The researchers said this suggests that louse-born diseases such as typhus and trench fever may have been a major factor contributing to Napoleon's retreat from Russia.
They believe analysing dental pulp for signs of DNA from infectious agents may become an important tool for investigating the history of communicable diseases.
Dr Carole Reeves, a medical historian, said it was ironic that teeth were now uncovering the health secrets of Napoleon's army, as they were widely savaged at the Battle of Waterloo in order to make dentures.
"Wherever there is warfare there is always infectious disease," she said.
"And up to World War I many deaths were caused by infectious disease rather than the warfare itself."


Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/health/4534540.stm

Published: 2005/12/18 23:53:04 GMT

© BBC MMV

ogukuo72
12-20-2005, 03:57 AM
From 500,000 to 3,000. That's an attrition of more than 99%!

Kilgor
12-20-2005, 06:14 AM
The germans didnt like the "little partisans" in Russia too much either.

Amazing the similiarities in the campaigns.

Asheren
12-20-2005, 06:19 AM
From The Journal of infectious diseases:
Volume 193(2006), pages 112 - 120
DOI:10.1086/498534

Abstract
Background. Many soldiers in Napoleon's Grand Army died of infectious diseases during its retreat from Russia. Because soldiers were commonly infested with body lice, it has been speculated that louse-borne infectious diseases, such as epidemic typhus (caused by Rickettsia prowazekii), were common.

Methods. We investigated this possibility during recent excavations of a mass grave of Napoleon's soldiers in Vilnius, Lithuania. Segments of 5 body lice, identified morphologically and by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and sequencing, were found in earth from the grave that also contained fragments of soldiers' uniforms.

Results. DNA of Bartonella quintana (the agent of trench fever) was identified by PCR and sequencing in 3 of the lice. Similarly, PCR and sequencing of dental pulp from the remains of 35 soldiers revealed DNA of B. quintana in 7 soldiers and DNA of R. prowazekii in 3 other soldiers.

Conclusions. Our results show that louse-borne infectious diseases affected nearly one-third of Napoleon's soldiers buried in Vilnius and indicate that these diseases might have been a major factor in the French retreat from Russia.

stonecutter
12-20-2005, 12:08 PM
From 500,000 to 3,000. That's an attrition of more than 99%!

That's ultimately what screwed France over -- such a great loss of experienced officers and men, which would have been crucial to have for later battles like Waterloo. As it was, Napoleon had to fight with pretty much a "green" army after that. Anyone know the true figures of Napoleon's losses in Russia? I've often read around 700,000 men lost (didn't he go in with 900,000?).
There was an article in a military history magazine last month I believe, which had information taken from memoirs written by a French officer during the retreat from Russia. During the cold march, the cavalrymen would cut and eat strips of meat from horses' hind quarters as they walked. Because of the extreme cold, the bleeding would stop, and these poor horses would often continue walking for several days with great chunks of muscle cut from their bones. What a nightmare.

Gordon
12-21-2005, 09:45 PM
Check out Adam Zamoyski's book Napolean's Fatal March on Moscow it's a very good book covering this event.

He concludes that it impossible to precisely establish the number of dead as the Grande Armee was continuously reinforced during its time in Russia. He reckons about 400,000 French and allied troops died of which only less than a quarter died in battle.

It seems precise figures will never be established.

Benny
12-23-2005, 12:09 PM
Great reading, ilustrated with realistic drawings!

Benny

stonecutter
12-23-2005, 01:38 PM
Thanks for that reference. I'll be sure to look it up!

Atlantic Friend
12-23-2005, 05:53 PM
Almost a week and nobody made a joke about Frenchmen, lice and lack of hygiene ? Aw, guys, what's with everyone being so serious, suddenly ? ;)

On a more serious note, it's amazing how non-military inventions as DDT and penicillin had a huge impact on operations. IIRC I read something about the difference of treatement in German and American field hospitals in WW2, with a much speedier quicker recovery in the latter...

foxtrot023
12-23-2005, 06:11 PM
Almost a week and nobody made a joke about Frenchmen, lice and lack of hygiene ? Aw, guys, what's with everyone being so serious, suddenly ? ;)

On a more serious note, it's amazing how non-military inventions as DDT and penicillin had a huge impact on operations. IIRC I read something about the difference of treatement in German and American field hospitals in WW2, with a much speedier quicker recovery in the latter...

It also helped that US casualties were evacuated much more faster due to the huge motorization in the army during WW2 while german wounded usually had to be evacuated by horse drawn wagons

Benny
12-23-2005, 08:59 PM
And let's not forget the huge number of disease casualties vs. battle casualties.

Maybe the Burma theatre of operations, in WWII, is one of the worse examples.

Benny

Bryson C
12-25-2005, 06:20 PM
Great read thx for posting it.