PDA

View Full Version : A Review i wrote on the movie "Osama"



EvanL
02-24-2004, 05:39 PM
I would appreciate your comments on this. Its for a non-fiction writing class that i am taking.

Imagine getting beaten for showing your ankle, or stoned for going outside

without your husband. That’s what it was like for the women of Afghanistan under the

rule of the Taliban, a regime of religious zealots intent on enforcing their twisted idea of

Islam upon the country in order to keep their people living in fear. For one afghani family

this lifestyle bears too much of a burden. The family cannot get any money, because they

have no man to support them and women are forbidden to work. For them it is a matter of

life or death. They are presented with few choices and resort to disguising their only

daughter as a boy, so that she may work and provide them with food.

This is the story of “Osama”, the first major Afghan movie produced after the fall of the

Taliban. Director Siddiq Barmak, leads the viewer through a world filled with fear and

uncertainty. The movie centres on a girl who is forced to disguise herself as a boy so that

she may work. She is employed by a man who fought beside her late father in the

Mujihadeen, a guerrilla group formed to counter Soviet invasion of Afghanistan during

the 80’s. Working for as little as a loaf of bread a day, the girl commits herself to the job

until one day when the Taliban came. She is taken along with all the boys in the

neighbourhood to a Madrassah (Islamic school) run by the Taliban and supported by the

Al-Qaeda terrorist organization which calls the country home. Here she is forced to learn

the Talibans idea of Islam. She befriends a streetwise boy named Espandi, who takes her

under his wing knowing that she is in disguise and sticks up for her when she is

confronted by suspicious children intent on revealing her identity. It is through Espandi

that she takes on the name Osama.

Inspired by a true story, Osama is a rare overtly political film that is surely a work of

cinematic wonder. You are sure not to recognize any faces or names in this movie, the

director using only real afghanis as the characters. In fact, it was while walking through

the impoverished streets of Kabul, that the director Siddiq Barmak found the actress who

plays Osama, begging him for change. This helps give the movie a more realistic feel to

it. Osama is a movie that will surely keep you thinking for weeks and asking yourself for

years how the world could have overlooked such a problem as the one faced by the

afghani people.

Trigger
02-24-2004, 05:44 PM
Well written.

You might want to capitalize 'afghani', but I'm not sure. Ask FG.

Is it a real movie?

cut
02-24-2004, 05:48 PM
yes

http://www.highfallsfilmfest.com/films/2003/osama.jpg


OSAMA (Feature, Afghanistan, 82 minutes). The first entirely Afghan film made after the fall of the Taliban is also the debut of director Siddiq Barmak. Based on a newspaper account Barmak read while in exile in Pakistan, it tells the harrowing story of a twelve-year-old-girl forced to a disguise herself as a boy in order to support her widowed mother and grandmother. She is soon rounded up and sent to a Taliban boys’ school, run by a monstrous mullah, in whom religious fanaticism and misogyny are inseparable. Working with limited resources and in chaotic conditions, Barmak has produced a film that is both raw and thoughtful, combining neorealism with elements of self-reflexivity, much in the manner of the Iranian master, Abbas Kiaristami. (Amy Taubin)

Vance
02-24-2004, 06:01 PM
The true spelling is Madrassa. Also there are many spelling of Mujihadeen, but the true spelling is Mujaheddin. Just little stuff like that.

Ratamacue
02-24-2004, 06:05 PM
There is no "true spelling" of Arabic words. They use an entirely different alphabet, and hence it's all based on phonics, hence why you might see words spelled different ways (i.e. Usama/Osama, Hussein/Husayn).

Vance
02-24-2004, 06:43 PM
There is no "true spelling" of Arabic words. They use an entirely different alphabet, and hence it's all based on phonics, hence why you might see words spelled different ways (i.e. Usama/Osama, Hussein/Husayn).
Well I got mine from a book that was translated from Arabic, and ironically it spells it different then any other English book I've read that has the word.

farmgirl
02-24-2004, 10:58 PM
Well written.

You might want to capitalize 'afghani', but I'm not sure. Ask FG.

Is it a real movie?

yes... capitalize Afghani.... and watch comma splices. Two complete sentences cannot be separated by only a conjunction..... there are three ways that you can do this correctly.....

For example....

I like beer but I don't like tequila. INCORRECT

1) I like beer, but I don't like tequila. Correct.... comma before the conjunction.

2) I like beer; I don't like tequila. Correct.....A semi colon acts as a period, but the ideas must be related.

3) I like beer. I don't like tequila. Correct.... make two sentences.


English 101.... lesson of the day. :)

Merik
02-24-2004, 11:05 PM
Well written.

You might want to capitalize 'afghani', but I'm not sure. Ask FG.

Is it a real movie?

yes... capitalize Afghani.... and watch comma splices. Two complete sentences cannot be separated by only a conjunction..... there are three ways that you can do this correctly.....

For example....

I like beer but I don't like tequila. INCORRECT

1) I like beer, but I don't like tequila. Correct.... comma before the conjunction.

2) I like beer; I don't like tequila. Correct.....A semi colon acts as a period, but the ideas must be related.

3) I like beer. I don't like tequila. Correct.... make two sentences.


English 101.... lesson of the day. :)


Mmmm I wonder if my student teacher is a beer and tequila fan, hopefully its a trait of all hot teachers.

By the way, who the hell cares if they make a movie that is even remotly related to Osama in a personal way?

farmgirl
02-24-2004, 11:12 PM
Well written.

You might want to capitalize 'afghani', but I'm not sure. Ask FG.

Is it a real movie?

yes... capitalize Afghani.... and watch comma splices. Two complete sentences cannot be separated by only a conjunction..... there are three ways that you can do this correctly.....

For example....

I like beer but I don't like tequila. INCORRECT

1) I like beer, but I don't like tequila. Correct.... comma before the conjunction.

2) I like beer; I don't like tequila. Correct.....A semi colon acts as a period, but the ideas must be related.

3) I like beer. I don't like tequila. Correct.... make two sentences.


English 101.... lesson of the day. :)


Mmmm I wonder if my student teacher is a beer and tequila fan, hopefully its a trait of all hot teachers.

By the way, who the hell cares if they make a movie that is even remotly related to Osama in a personal way?


Of course that was only an example.... Jose Cuervo is a friend of mine..... ;)

Merik
02-24-2004, 11:26 PM
Hehehe yeeeaaahhhh. woot woot