PDA

View Full Version : Fraudulent enlistment: one soldier's story



BadKarma26
05-08-2006, 05:28 PM
Hopefully this hasn't been posted before. Its 3 years old, but I did a search and nothing came up. Interesting read, hope ya'll enjoy.

Full Metal Strait Jacket
By Becky Oberg

My battle buddy reminds me to drink more water and tries to check my alertness. My attention is elsewhere -- another soldier is at the clinic desk. He is clutching a paper and seems too alert to be another heat casualty.

"I have asthma and I want out," he tells the sergeant.

Asthma! In Indianapolis, a military counselor told my group of prospects about an asthmatic young man who'd concealed his condition. He went off his medication and inhaler. He died from a severe asthma attack during Basic training.

The sergeant glares at the paper. It is a Moment of Truth (MOT) sheet -- meaning the soldier confessed a disqualifying condition during a last chance for amnesty. The sergeant scowls, and roughly hands the sheet back to the soldier.

"You just wasted $30,000 of your country's money," he says.

I shudder, thinking about my own MOT condition. No, not me, I say to myself. That won't happen to me. I don't want out. I want this bad enough. I'm strong and some discipline will keep this in check.

One week later my MOT condition will put me in the hospital.


"No means numerous opportunities; yes means your enlistment stops"

Fraudulent enlistment is neither new nor unusual in the Army. During World War II, some young men falsified their birth certificates in order to enlist. Today, people lie about medical conditions, criminal records or financial obligations. Technically, fraudulent enlistment is a crime: The maximum penalty in military court is a dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances and two years confinement.

This is stated at the Military Entrance Processing Station (MEPS), and prospects are warned to not trust their recruiters. Prospects are asked if they were coached to lie -- as if someone will answer in the affirmative when asked, "Are you lying?" Concealed disqualifying conditions are part of the reason 40 percent of military recruits do not finish their full term of service.

My recruiter repeatedly said, "No means numerous opportunities, yes means your enlistment stops." He would ask me, "Your favorite answer on the physical is?" and point to me, which was my cue to answer in the negative.

He told me I wasn't the first person he'd advised to conceal a condition. One prospect was allergic to strawberries. He told her, "Don't eat strawberries," told her to say she wasn't allergic to anything and sent her for the physical.

When I swore in after the physical, my recruiter introduced me to another prospect. He told her to ask me anything about the physical. I gave her a brief rundown of what the physical was like, some advice on making weight and what to wear. My recruiter nodded, then turned to her and said, "What's your favorite answer on the physical?"

"No," she replied. She passed the physical and signed up for a counterintelligence position. Sometimes I wonder what she concealed.

Why do the prospects lie? The reasons vary. I lied because I wanted to serve my country in the armed forces. I'd been laid off from my job as a reporter when the recession started, and had worked in a restaurant for more than a year. I wanted to do a job that mattered. The military was the only option I thought I had -- a common sentiment among many soldiers. While I was nervous about lying, my recruiter reminded me, "No means numerous opportunities, yes means your enlistment stops."

Why do some recruiters coach their prospects to lie? They are required to meet quotas -- and it is easy to understand the temptation to look the other way when an otherwise desirable prospect has a concealable disqualifying condition.

This happens often enough that about.com has a question about it in the FAQs about joining the military. Ron Powers, a retired Air Force sergeant who writes for about.com, alluded to this problem in his article "What the Recruiter Never Told You" and dealt with it specifically in his article "I Cannot Tell a Lie" (see sidebar). The Army knows some recruits lie, hence the warning at MEPS and the MOT briefing. The MOT briefing is a soldier's last chance to avoid an Article 15 for fraudulent enlistment.

During my platoon's MOT briefing, Lt. Morris explains that his job is to keep us in the Army. He is the wrong person to talk to about discharges. However, if we have disqualifying conditions we've lied about and would now like to reveal, he has the forms. He says he's heard everything and cleared many soldiers to go to Basic training.

More than half of us come forward to confess our conditions. They vary, from a misdemeanor weapons charge to a psychiatric hospitalization. I step up, stand at attention and hand him my paper. He reads it and looks at me. "How do you feel?"

"Ready to report, sir!" I bark. In spite of my condition and the fact that none of us know the latest about the Iraqi war, I am eager to train. I have accepted the fact that I will probably kill and could die. I am ready to fight.

He signs the paper, clearing me to go to Basic. My condition is on record and unofficially waived. If the background investigation for my top-secret security clearance reveals I was treated for depression while in college, I will not be charged with fraudulent enlistment.

Continued here: http://www.duckdaotsu.org/full_metal_oberg.html

Hydro
05-08-2006, 05:45 PM
In a world where people are joining only to flee when war kicks off and the military seems about as popular as a suspect wet fart, it's very admirable (if foolish in some cases) that some folk are going to such lengths to serve in the military.

XShipRider
05-08-2006, 06:16 PM
A good physical should have caught these conditions. Complete medical
history with medical records release should be a pre-requisite.

el borracho
05-08-2006, 06:42 PM
But then you got lots of people doing the opposite and milking minor medical conditions just to get out. Either way, once you're in the process takes several months, if not years before a decision is made. I know people that will actually end up finishing their enlistment before a final decision is made based on their case. You might think the military is stalling just to get the full commitment out of someone, but the reality is many troops get placed on light duty or profile for things like that...yet they don't receive any adverse treatment or punishment. I remember during a PT session in the dead of summer (down in Georgia no less) an NCO yells at some kid to pick up the pace, someone corrects the NCO and says "go easy on him, he has asthma" and the guy got to walk the whole time. Meanwhile people who didn't lie during their recruitment start to stumble around the third mile or so and get a full ripping by the same NCO for slowing down. Something ain't right with that picture.

You might think that's admirable or patriotic when people conceal conditions like that, but sooner or later it's going to come out. By then they may end up using thousands in tax dollars for treatment, or heaven forbid be unable to perform when the bullets start flying. Troops need to function at 100%. It sucks for those who want to join and can't...but for others' sake they just can't risk it.

Maine Finn
05-08-2006, 06:56 PM
But then you got lots of people doing the opposite and milking minor medical conditions just to get out. Either way, once you're in the process takes several months, if not years before a decision is made. I know people that will actually end up finishing their enlistment before a final decision is made based on their case. You might think the military is stalling just to get the full commitment out of someone, but the reality is many troops get placed on light duty or profile for things like that...yet they don't receive any adverse treatment or punishment. I remember during a PT session in the dead of summer (down in Georgia no less) an NCO yells at some kid to pick up the pace, someone corrects the NCO and says "go easy on him, he has asthma" and the guy got to walk the whole time. Meanwhile people who didn't lie during their recruitment start to stumble around the third mile or so and get a full ripping by the same NCO for slowing down. Something ain't right with that picture.

You might think that's admirable or patriotic when people conceal conditions like that, but sooner or later it's going to come out. By then they may end up using thousands in tax dollars for treatment, or heaven forbid be unable to perform when the bullets start flying. Troops need to function at 100%. It sucks for those who want to join and can't...but for others' sake they just can't risk it.

And unfortunately, a good number of those people who conceal medical conditions somehow get through BCT, and AIT, in some cases, despite repeated visits to TMC for difficulties with their conditions. These soldiers then end up in the operational Army, where their units will ultimately have to carry them in some fashion or get rid of them.

More strigent medical background checks would help reduce the number of people who manage to conceal various conditions, but... where there's a will, there's a way. Not all of them can be prevented from enlisting, no matter their intentions.

Hydro
05-08-2006, 06:58 PM
You might think that's admirable or patriotic when people conceal conditions like that, but sooner or later it's going to come out.



Oh for sure, that's why I said it was sometimes foolish. I agree totally with soldiers having to be 100% of sound mind and body in order to complete their jobs.

Something to consider would be the use of what would be currently classed as medically unfit personnel in non-deployable home defence roles, such as stagging on at airports, admin, armourers, and so forth, maybe freeing up more deployable troops? You still get the chance to serve, maybe not as hugely glamorous as storming every beach from here to Saipan but if you're serious about it...

RobertStacked
05-08-2006, 07:13 PM
A good physical should have caught these conditions. Complete medical
history with medical records release should be a pre-requisite.



Obviously your not in the medical field. Nor have you served in combat arms. I have seen people, E-5's and up, suddenly develop medical problems/serious disorders (seizures, catatonia, ad etc.) late in their military careers. Sometimes it was tied to a pre-existing condition that had often escaped the PA's and doctors (earlier on) but more often then not, It just happened.

el borracho
05-08-2006, 08:22 PM
To Hydro:

They've thought of doing stuff like that before. And many of those people waiting to get out for medical reasons get reclassed into temporary jobs like that. The thing is they can't enlist people with certain conditions for those jobs because it would create a "second class soldier." That troop would be looked down upon by those more capable. Plus issues regarding rank (should an unfit troop be allowed to be promoted, should they be allowed to give orders to other troops?, etc.) and it makes things too complicated.