PDA

View Full Version : Japanese veteran admits vivisection tests on PoWs



J-10
11-28-2006, 09:58 AM
Japanese veteran admits vivisection tests on PoWs
Justin McCurry in Tokyo
Monday November 27, 2006
Guardian Unlimited

http://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-images/Guardian/Pix/pictures/2006/11/27/Japan372.jpg
A Chinese woman visits the ruins of the yellow-rat breeding room at the Japanese germ warfare centre operated by Unit 731, near the Chinese city of Harbin. Photograph: Jason Lee/*******


Japan has again been forced to confront its wartime conduct after a former doctor in the country's imperial navy admitted he had conducted experiments on Filipino prisoners during the second world war.

Akira Makino, 84, said in an interview with the Kyodo news agency that he had performed surgery and amputations on dozens of prisoners of war before they were executed in the Philippines.

Several veterans have admitted conducting human vivisection in northern China as part of Japan's wartime chemical and biological weapons programme, but experts say Mr Makino is the first to testify that similar atrocities took place in south-east Asia.

Mr Makino said that as a 22-year-old he had operated on about 30 prisoners between December 1944 and February 1945 while working as a medic on the island of Mindanao.

As part of his medical training he said he had been ordered to conduct amputations, abdominal dissections and other experiments on condemned men, women and children, including two men who had been beaten unconscious for allegedly spying for the US.

After sedating the men by placing ether-soaked cloths over their faces, he was instructed to make an incision with a surgical knife and study their livers.

"I thought, 'What a horrible thing I am doing to innocent people, even though I had been ordered to do it,'" he told Kyodo.

Mr Makino said he was too scared to refuse. "I would have been killed if I had disobeyed the order," he said. "That's how it was in those days."

Filipino patients who survived their ordeal were strangled with rope.
Mr Makino is one of several former Japanese soldiers who decided to reveal the truth about their country's use of human guinea pigs before they die.

Unit 731, the imperial Japanese army's notorious germ warfare unit, killed thousands of Chinese civilians and Allied PoWs at its sprawling complex in Harbin, northern China, from the late 1930s until the end of the war.

The victims, named "logs" by their torturers, were injected with typhus, cholera and other diseases. They died during the experiments or were executed to prevent them from talking about their experiences.

As the end of the war approached, the unit destroyed evidence of their activities, releasing infected animals and dumping chemicals into rivers. The extent of their activities only came to light following testimony from repentant former doctors, soldiers and nurses.

Hal Gold, author of Unit 731:Testimony, said Mr Makino was typical of medical students and young doctors who were sent overseas by their superiors. "A lot of those guys didn't have a choice," said.

"They had to follow orders, so it's hard to pass a moral judgment on people like that. As you go further down the line of command, many of them didn't know what they were getting into. If they refused orders, it was the end of their medical careers."

With many surviving former members of the unit now in their 80s and 90s, he said Mr Makino may be among the last to talk frankly about their work.
"There's a pretty slim prospect of anyone in authority coming forward," he said. "Our only hope is that someone discovers a letter or a diary, something that may have been hidden by the family because they were ashamed."

The US authorities secretly granted unit officials immunity from prosecution in return for access to years of research into biological weapons. Several former Unit 731 officials went on to enjoy prominent careers in medicine, academia and business, including its former leader, Dr Masaji Kitano, who headed Green Cross, once Japan's biggest pharmaceutical company.

Mr Makino, who lives near Osaka, said he remained haunted by memories of the experiments and had ignored friends who urged him to take his secret to the grave. "We should not repeat that misery again," he said. "I want to tell the truth about the war."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/japan/story/0,,1958158,00.html?gusrc=rss&feed=12

Johnny_H02
11-28-2006, 10:13 AM
"They had to follow orders, so it's hard to pass a moral judgment on people like that. As you go further down the line of command, many of them didn't know what they were getting into. If they refused orders, it was the end of their medical careers."
This is total BS, of course its easy to pass moral judgment, I dont see how if it was easy to do so for the Nazi's why it would differ for the Japanese.

Just following orders stopped being a valid excuse due to the second world war.

Hunterhr
11-28-2006, 12:39 PM
If they refused orders, it was the end of their medical careers."

Oh well then. Perfectly understandable.

Mastermind
11-29-2006, 01:25 PM
I think one must be the subject of the "illegal order" before making a judgememnt...I know for a fact I would do many things I would not ordinarily do if someone put a gun to my head and said..."Decide NOW!"

That said, I also have had the experience of refusing illegal orders...even questionable orders in combat situations....I refused an order to torture a prisoner...I did not get punished...even though the CO was highly pissed at me and threatened serious punishment....and the funny thing is, my adamant refusal put enough doubt in him to make him stop the effort (at least in front of witnesses)...to my knowledge, the torture never took place after I refused. So, a strong enough soldier can refuse illegal order...at least in the American Army in Vietnam...I have also read concentration camp guards were allowed to refuse certain orders....of course, they were often then shipped to other more harsh or dangerous duties...but I have never heard or read of of a nazi regime guard being executed for punished for refusal to murder or abuse prisoners.

WWII Japan is another case...I know they had a tremendous social pressure to comply with orders. Refusal probably meant having to commit suicide or face dire shame on the family and self, a fate perhaps worse than death to them.

Just my 2 cents worth on it...good topic.MM