Egypt debate: Israel enemy or adversary?

[EITAN88]

Honestly, I don't want the Sinai.

If Israel were ever to take control of the Sinai it would be due to security reasons... not economic or political.

We wouldn't have a choice in other words.

[BlackWarder]

If Israel were ever to take control of the Sinai it would be due to security reasons... not economic or political.

We wouldn't have a choice in other words.

I would rather make it a Bedouin outonomy, the place is a powder keg waiting for a spark.

Warder

[EITAN88]

I would rather make it a Bedouin outonomy, the place is a powder keg waiting for a spark.

Warder

This whole region is a powder keg.

Your idea for a Bedouin autonomy is interesting nontheless.

[Camera]

When Israel controlled Sinai there were no security concerns with the Bedouins. I've been the for long periods.

[BlackWarder]

When Israel controlled Sinai there were no security concerns with the Bedouins. I've been the for long periods.

That was 30 years ago, times change.

Warder

[EITAN88]

When Israel controlled Sinai there were no security concerns with the Bedouins. I've been the for long periods.

Times have changed.

The bombings of the Hilton Taba and the Sharem resort as well as the continues sabotage of the NG pipeline prove that this isn't the same Sinai we gave back to the Egyptians.

[Camera]

Sure… They went mad since then.

[Climber]

Bedouin autonomy under our security check and sponsorship would be a good idea.

[IraGlacialis]

Bedouin autonomy under our security check and sponsorship would be a good idea.

I'd be curious to know how a Bedouin autonomous state (I take serving as a buffer state as well) would align itself between Egypt and Israel, even if Israel is sponsoring them.
The Bedouins have seemed relatively neutral (or maybe antagonistic/opportunistic towards both sides) on the whole issue.

[Climber]

I'd be curious to know how a Bedouin autonomous state (I take serving as a buffer state as well) would align itself between Egypt and Israel, even if Israel is sponsoring them.
The Bedouins have seemed relatively neutral (or maybe antagonistic/opportunistic towards both sides) on the whole issue.

Bedouins in Israel serve in the IDF, they are very proud and free people who respects force. I think they respect us more than they respect our southern cousins. But is just my subjective opinion.
The thing is they make big money with contraband, along with Israelis lowlifes, and of course smuggling weapons to the palis. I think we can agree on a solution with them its all about money.....

[kamazz]

wheres that shelata guy to defend the idiocy of his country?

[Climber]

wheres that shelata guy to defend the idiocy of his country?

He was suspended for trolling, never came back...never learned to moderate his views or the ways of the forum.

[J.Noah ה]

He was suspended for trolling, never came back...never learned to moderate his views or the ways of the forum.

Sadly his trolling is his honest opinions.

[Climber]

Sadly his trolling is his honest opinions.

true, culturally he couldn't bring any self criticism or view things with a grain of salt.

[BlackWarder]

Bedouin autonomy under our security check and sponsorship would be a good idea.

It's a deal than, who wants to tell the Egyptians and Bedouin about our dicision.

Warder