Though, the Fuchs seemes to have held up quite good against the Bomb.
Was there a KWS applied to the Fuchs' ?
Last edited by CptGonzo; 11-16-2008 at 05:18 PM.
Well I wouldnt call the Dingo worthless, its a fine vehicle.
The Dingo have a much better protected cell than every fox.
Originally Posted by Tim292
Especially against mines. We saw what happend as that Dingo drove over stacked Mines, the engine was completely blown away and everything was brunt but the hull was still intact!
I know about the better protection of the Dingo. Still, I disagree with the whole concept of Dingo/Eagle. The Duro, I agree, might be a different matter and is quite a usefull vehicle.
First of, the RCWS on all vehicles decreases situational awareness a whole lot. Nothing beats manned machine guns when it comes to sit.awareness and the possibility to quickly engage on the move!
Secondly, Dingo doesn't even offer more than one hatchet in the roof. Emergency exits, shooting out of hatchets and communication with the outside is barely possibly.
Thirdly, and most importantly is patrol setup.
one force protection platoon, a Cimic team, a BAT, a bunch of WBV 'soldiers' for shopping
Now, cram all those people into 'their' vehicles..
FP Platoon: 3squads, 2 Dingos each, 1 c2 dingo for the platoon commander
Cimic team: 1 eagle/wolf
WBV: another Dingo
That's a total of 8 Dingos and 2 other vehicles, column length of well above 300meters. It's just hard to control, ineffective to lead and has a much higher chance of one vehicle breaking down and halting the column.
I always preferred small setups:
f.e. my FP platoon in 3 Füchsen, the Wbv/comic guys and my platoon leading section in another Fuchs(no need to use a c2 version..) and the BAT in their own vehicle. It's tight, easy to control and I just have one combat ineffective vehicle in my column, the column has half the size and twice the speed.
A Fuchs offers significantly better mobility over a Dingo and it practically has the same size.
Dont get me wrong, I'm all in love with Dingos good level of protection - but not at that price.
I rather have 10 soldiers in one less protected vehicle with way better situational awareness than 5 perfectly sheltered soldiers in 2 vehicles, slow to move and respond and totally isolated from the world outside.
Scrap the GFF, concentrate on:
Wolf MSA, Mungos and Wiesel for airborne
Wolf SSA, Fuchs and Fuchs with a 20-30mm BMK
Wolf SSA, Boxer and Boxer with 30mm BMK
Edit: Oh, and I'm totally aware that this is never going to happen with the Bundeswehr. Props to the French with their VABs, armed VAPs and VBLs.
Thank you for your insight, seems to make sense.
Just one thing, you proposed the Mungo as a patrol vehicle like it is used now. Do you really think it is suitable for that task?
I didn't really propose the Mungo as a patrol vehicle, but you're right, my post wasn't very clear about that. Also, I'm not much of an expert concerning the Mungo, I just don't have too much experience with that vehicle.
Still, in my opinion the Mungo is a damn fine vehicle and close to perfect for what it was designed for:
- as many fully equipped boots as possible
- under the best protection possible
- for up to 50km
- after air-insertion by helo/c160.
However, as a general patrol vehicle and with special regard to it's constantly breaking axles in A'stan, it's just not suited for such kind of missions.
But like I said in my above post, I'd still choose a few Mungos over a dozen Eagles if the terrain doesn't allow anything bigger. And as long as there's enough supplies rolling in and the mechanics are fast to fix the vehicles, I couldn't care less if I'd get a new axle every two weeks.
Nah, problem with the mungo is that the armor just goes up to chest level.
They use the IdZ Sk4 vests for extra armor AFAIK!
But I agree with you. Sad that the 20mm BmK Füchse never got realised.
Seriously, a 20mm BmK is useless against the current IED threat. It only helps in possible ambushes after the explosion. Most important is to have protected Vehicles for every movement outside the Base in Afghanistan.
Originally Posted by CptGonzo
Sadly, there is a lack of usable vehicles for that.
The new Eagle IV is not really smaller than a Dingo, so there will be few places that you can reach with it where you couldn't already go with a Dingo.
With the problems in finding a suitable vehicle for the GFF class 1 (less than 5.3t), the Bundeswehr is stuck with the different Wolf vehicles or the Mungo which are either mostly unprotected (Wolf MSS, MSA), unarmed (Wolf SSA) or only partially armored and ****e to break down or turn over (Mungo).
And then, even the armed vehicles in that class don't have a 360 degree traversable gun mount, so the machine gunner can't lay suppresive fire during an ambush ... really not a great situation.
Are there any possible solutions for that?
Very nice. I love the Congo video, and several of the pictures from the A-stan video were new to me.
Why are they new for you? The most pictures of the A'stan vid, can you find in this thread...
Tags for this Thread