Thread: Yum Kippur War

  1. #2956
    On Belay... Climb on Climber's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Buenos Aires in body, the beautiful and green Sharon in my heart
    Age
    45
    Posts
    10,157

    Default

    Sometime ago i saw a girl that made me remember Dinah, a volunteer that came to work on a Kibbutz, why is she here? She said that she couldn't stay in America, She have to do something, there are many like her, Students, Professionals, bussines men and women, from England and other parts of Europe, from the United states, from everywhere, they fill the vacant jobs in the city and in the fields, we really need them, and we gratefully respect them, and about you, I know you could't came, but I know you were with us, spiritually, from the first time, when everybody abandoned us, you love, your affect, your support more than ever, was what made us keep going on the worse times, I really know we were on your hearts, and believe me, you also were on ours, maybe here is the essence of everything, the intense feeling of unity, you, us, Israel. I felt it very strong some days, when we finally were coming back to our base. Our bus, stopped in a kibbutz, and there, like in many places in Israel, the people prepared food and drinks under the trees, for the soldiers. It was erev shabbat, there was sandwichs, wine, and hot coffee. I don't know why but suddenly I felt tears in my eyes, I felt everybody so close, the girls that were serving us the food, the kibbutznikims, the crazy soldiers from this crazy civilian army, I wanted to hug everyone and everybody, and I am sure I wasn't the only one that felt like that. That way, we shared everything, good and bad, nobody here is an isolated being, what affects one, affects everybody, and slowly, gradually we are starting to discover the real cost of this war, inside us, its burns like a white hot iron, In teh Hospitals, the injured guys, laugh and flirt with the nurses, their moral looks good, but after what happened, I really don't know how they do it.

    Meanwhile, now, I am laying at the sunlight, touching the ground with my fingers.......I am alive..........I am whole..........I am happy about it, but I can't forget what others endured, what others gave. All kinds of thoughts came to my mind, about this country, the hard time we are living, nothing will be the same as it was, and I ask myself repeatedly, where are we going, and the meaning of all of this, and curiously, this war, to me, brought Israel closer to my heart, my bonds with my country, today, are deeper than ever, closer than ever. I look Ruthy, and the little ones, I look around me, and after all, even all, this is teh best place for them to grow up.
    Well, what else to say, We love you, we miss you, and like we say here, Up with the hearts (Tachsiku ma'amad)........
    Well after finishing, Its clear that the letter was written for the documentary, i don't believe its an actual letter. And It could have been written in Hebrew and translated to many languages.

    Anyway, I liked it, it made me to remember forgotten feelings, people that's not here anymore, people that paid the ultimate price to give me the possibility of being what I am. They give me the possibility of having a family, everything.
    Gracias.

  2. #2957
    Senior Member Camera's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    France
    Age
    54
    Posts
    13,988

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Climber View Post
    Well after finishing, Its clear that the letter was written for the documentary, i don't believe its an actual letter. And It could have been written in Hebrew and translated to many languages.

    Anyway, I liked it, it made me to remember forgotten feelings, people that's not here anymore, people that paid the ultimate price to give me the possibility of being what I am. They give me the possibility of having a family, everything.
    Gracias.
    The first part of the text, the one you translated yesterday, was better and seemed more authentic. I think it was this second part with its patriotic message that gave me the impression the voiceover was lousy, even if I did not understand the contact. It smells the “Jewish Agency“, which contributed to finance the documentary.

    The roller credits “A. Rosenthal“ for writing the narrative.
    Was the letter a real or not?
    I agree with you, it was written for the, to match its editing.
    But the author could have started with a real letter, or even with more than one real letter, to render its text more authentic, and then could have adapted it for the film editing, and then aded some additional texts, necessity to the documentary. (I know what I'm saying, I'm in the movies business.)

    Thank you for sharing with us the time you spent to translate the content. And toda raba for your great job.

  3. #2958
    Senior Member Camera's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    France
    Age
    54
    Posts
    13,988

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by rolist View Post
    http://www.421.co.il/ for those who understand Hebrew, addtional footage of communication was added to the veb site
    Rollist,
    The footage you aded from the communication networks is incredible. All the events — that occurred from towing the crossing equipment at 15/16 October night to the battles on the West Bank at 16 and 17 October — are there.
    Also, your site made a great job on the quality of the presentation — edition of the recordings, the visual illustrations, the subtitles… All that contributes to the clarity.

    I believe it is very useful to all those who are interested in History. The authentic material is so valuable, because their are so many books with mistakes and even the memory of those who have been there sometime fails after all those years.
    One example: I remember few years ago a discussion between veterans on Fresh forum. Most of them pretended that in the morning of October 16, there were AT ambushes on Akavish road. Other veterans pretended it was not the case and that the road was completely open. And here, on your footage, one can hear the voices on the networks of the officers that were involved in rescuing battalion commander Ben Shoshan and the 2 other tanks of his battalion ambusehd on Akavish in the morning of October 16!

    Thank you and go on with this great job!
    Last edited by Camera; 06-16-2011 at 09:24 AM.

  4. #2959
    Member Swarovski's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    ישראל
    Posts
    191

    Default

    Not 100% related to this thread, yet couldn't find a better place to post this:
    War of Attrition - new pictures posted in Ynet.


    Original (Hebrew):
    http://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-4082921,00.html

    Google Translated:
    http://translate.google.com/translat...n&hl=&ie=UTF-8

    Swarovski.

  5. #2960

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Camera View Post
    Rollist,
    The footage you aded from the communication networks is incredible. All the events — that occurred from towing the crossing equipment at 15/16 October night to the battles on the West Bank at 16 and 17 October — are there.
    Also, your site made a great job on the quality of the presentation — edition of the recordings, the visual illustrations, the subtitles… All that contributes to the clarity.

    I believe it is very useful to all those who are interested in History. The authentic material is so valuable, because their are so many books with mistakes and even the memory of those who have been there sometime fails after all those years.
    One example: I remember few years ago a discussion between veterans on Fresh forum. Most of them pretended that in the morning of October 16, there were AT ambushes on Akavish road. Other veterans pretended it was not the case and that the road was completely open. And here, on your footage, one can hear the voices on the networks of the officers that were involved in rescuing battalion commander Ben Shoshan and the 2 other tanks of his battalion ambusehd on Akavish in the morning of October 16!

    Thank you and go on with this great job!
    Many thanks for your kind words
    The crossing actually started very early morning -

  6. #2961
    Senior Member Camera's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    France
    Age
    54
    Posts
    13,988

    Default Unreleased amateur footage from the Syrian front 1973

    Amos Yodan was in an holiday visit in Israel when the war started. He joined his reserve unit, recce company of armor Brigade 4, part of Peled's Division. His brigade participated in pushing the Syrian forces back on the Golan and in the counter attack inside Syrian territory.
    During the war he used his personal 8mm camera to film.

    The following 48 minutes film includes all the footage taken by Amos during the war and after the cease-fire deep inside Syrian territory.
    The pictures are commented by Amos Yodan and Giora Ashkenazi, the commander of his recce company. They give many details about the war, the places seen in the footage, and their comrades which appear in the film, some of them were killed later during the fightings. The comments are in HEBREW.

    The film starts with both men presenting themselves, and the historical footage starts in the 6th minute with some family vacation pictures taken by Amos before the war erupted.


    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...4FbeLg8Q#at=15
    Last edited by Camera; 07-25-2011 at 08:48 AM.

  7. #2962
    Senior Member Kaplanr's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Eating eggs & hash browns. Nahal %^&*@strong 111.
    Posts
    5,933

    Default

    Unbelievable footage. Love the "coos emuck, dafku li et ha loof." at 15:50. Also the Mirage drop tank in the mutsav near the end.

  8. #2963

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by camera View Post
    amos yodan was in an holiday visit in israel when the war started. He jointed his reserve unit, recce company of armor brigade 4, part peled's division. His brigade participated in pushing the syrian forces back on the golan and in the counter attack inside syrian territory.
    During the war he used his personal 8mm to film.

    The following 48 minutes film includes all the footage taken by amos during the war and after the cease-fire deep in syrian territory.
    The pictures are commented by amos amos yodan and giora ashkenazi, the commander of the recce company. They give many details about the war, the places seen in the footage, and their comrades filmed, some of them were killed later during the fightings. The comments are in hebrew.


    The film starts with both men presenting themselves, and the historical footage starts minute 6 with some family vacation footage taken before the war erupted.


    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature...4fbelg8q#at=15
    [*******black][font=times new roman]
    [*******black][font=times new roman]what a documented piece of history – thanks for sharing it with us [/font][/color]
    [*******black][font=times new roman]as a tankie in who was in the southern, i can see a lot of similarities as to how poorly we were prepared [/font][/color]
    [*******black][font=times new roman] [/font][/color]
    [/font][/color]

  9. #2964
    Senior Member GB_FXST's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Arizona
    Posts
    6,517

    Default

    Very interesting video.

    I found this too to be interesting as Sabena is reunited with her letter.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCQl1...eature=related

  10. #2965
    Senior Member Camera's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Location
    France
    Age
    54
    Posts
    13,988

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by GB_FXST View Post
    Very interesting video.

    I found this too to be interesting as Sabena is reunited with her letter.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCQl1...eature=related
    Well we should explain in few words what is it about for the members that do not understand Hebrew.
    These are two short reports from Israeli Channel 10, each of them is 5 minutes long.

    In the first report, some veteran friends of Amos watch the footage. At one moment, we see a Syrian captured BTR and we see a close-up of an hand written letter in Hebrew by a child. The veterans of Amos' company tell that they found the letter in a Syrian BTR with other goods previously captured by the Syrian crew in an Israeli fort on the Golan. The letter which Amos filmed in a close-up, written by an Israeli child to a soldier, was inside a kitbag.

    In the second report, Amos meets with Sabena, the woman who wrote the letter. Back in 1973, she was 10-11 years old.
    Last edited by Camera; 07-27-2011 at 08:10 AM.

  11. #2966
    Senior Member shelata's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Port Saeid- EGYPT
    Posts
    1,368

    Default

    This is the story of one of the most important battles of 1973 war. It is the Suez city defence against IDF attacks on the 24th till the 26th of Oct. The target of the Israeli attacks were to occupy the city. This came in the latest stage of IDF violation of the UN ceasefire decision that was declared on the 22nd of OCT. This decision was approved by the confronting war sides & the security council members. Yet, by this date, IDF was far beyond its schedule that was employed since the failure of the Eg army 14th of OCT attack. According to this schedule, IDF was supposed to have crossed the Canal & should have executed a siege on the 2nd & 3rd armies prior to the issuance of a ceasefire decision. While Sharon Div advance in the northern front towards Ismaeilia city was halted by the Eg special forces , Adan & Kalman divisions were more succeesful in the southern front. The following photo is an evidence of the tough resistance that stopped Sharon division advance



    Although of the tough resistance, Adan & Kalman div were advancing slowly towards Suez City. The 22nd seized IDF away of its targetted goals. Accordingly, IDF broke the ceasefire & continued its attack in the direction of Suez. By the dawn of the 23rd, Kalman Div cut the main supply route of the 3rd army to Cairo. On the dawn of the 24th, Adabya port was occupied to cut the secondary supply route of the 3rd army. Now the 3rd army was surrounded.
    IDF planned to strengthen his position in the post war negotiation by occupying the city of Suez which became surrounded by IDF troops. The offensive continued from 24th till the 26th of OCT. But the result was another disaster for IDF which symbolized the outcome of this war. Here is a breif descrition of the battle :-
    [SIZE="3"]Defensive Combat Power: Suez – 1973 At the end of October, the Israeli Army was in the midst of effective counterattack against the Egyptian Army. The Israelis had success attacking west across the Suez Canal. Their armored divisions were attempting to achieve several objectives, to include destroying Egyptian air defense sites and completing the encirclement of the Egyptian 3rd Army, which was trapped on the canal’s east side. To completely encircle the Egyptian 3rd Army, the Israelis had to seize all possible crossing sites to it from the canal’s west bank and the Red Sea. Also, as international negotiations towards a cease-fire progressed, the Israeli government wanted to capture as much Egyptian territory as possible to improve their negotiating position after hostilities. Consequently, the Israeli Adan Armored Division was tasked to seize the Egyptian Red Sea port of Suez on the morning of 24 October. A cease-fire was to begin at 0700, and the Israeli intent was to be decisively engaged in the city by that time and then consolidate their position as part of the cease-fire compliance. The Adan Division plan to seize Suez was a two-part operation. Each of the division’s armored brigades would have a role. The 460th Brigade would attack west of the city and complete the city’s encirclement. Simultaneously, the 217th Brigade would attack in columns of battalions through the city to seize three key intersections in the city. This was in accordance with standard Israeli armored doctrine for fighting in an urban area. The 217th Brigade would seize its objectives through speed, firepower, and shock action. Once the objectives were seized, infantry and armored teams would continue attacking from the secured objectives to mop up and destroy pockets of resistance. The Israeli commanders expected to demoralize the defending Egyptians—two infantry battalions and one antitank company—by this rapid attack. The armored division commander was specifically advised by his commander to avoid a “Stalingrad” situation. The attack got off to an ominous beginning as mist greatly inhibited a scheduled aerial bombardment in support of the attack. The 217th Brigade began its attack without infantry support and was quickly stopped by antitank missiles and antitank fire. Infantry was quickly integrated into the brigade and the attack resumed. At the first objective, the Israelis encountered their first problems. A withering barrage of small arms, antitank missiles, and antitank fire hit the lead tank battalion, including direct fire from SU-23 anti-aircraft guns. Virtually all the officers and tank commanders in the tank battalion were killed or wounded, and several tanks were destroyed. Disabled vehicles blocked portions of the road, and vehicles that turned on to secondary roads were ambushed and destroyed. The battalion, however, successfully fought its way through the first brigade objective and on to the final brigade objective. Hastily attached paratroop infantry in company strength were next in column following the tanks. They were traveling in buses and trucks. As the lead tank battalion took fire, the paratroopers dismounted, and attempted to secure adjacent buildings. The tank battalion’s action of fighting through the objective caused the paratroopers to mount up and also attempt to move through the objective. Because of their soft skinned vehicles the paratroopers were unable to remain mounted and again dismounted, assaulted, and secured several buildings that they could defend. Once inside the buildings, the paratroopers found they were cut off, pinned down, and unable to evacuate their considerable casualties, which included the battalion commander. The paratroopers were on the initial brigade objective but were unable to maneuver and were taking casualties. A second paratroop company also dismounted and quickly became stalled in house-to-house fighting. The brigade reconnaissance company in M113 personnel carriers brought up the rear of the brigade column and lost several vehicles and was also unable to advance.
    By 1100 the Israeli attack culminated. Elements of the 217th Brigade were on all three of the brigade’s objectives in the city. However, the armored battalion, which had achieved the deepest penetration, was without infantry support and under severe antitank fire. Both paratroop companies were isolated and pinned down. In addition, an attempt to link up with the paratroopers had failed. At the same time, the civilian population of the city began to react. They erected impromptu barriers, ambushed isolated Israeli troops, and carried supplies and information to Egyptian forces. The Israeli division commander ordered the brigade to break contact and fight its way out of the city. The armored battalion was able to fight its way out in daylight. The paratroop companies were forced to wait until darkness and then infiltrated out of the city carrying their wounded with them. Israeli casualties totaled 88 killed and hundreds wounded in addition to 28 combat vehicles destroyed. Egyptian casualties were unknown but not believed to be significant. The fight for Suez effectively demonstrates numerous urban defensive techniques. It also vividly demonstrates the significant effect on defensive combat power of the urban environment. The Egyptian defense demonstrates how the compartmented urban terrain restricts the mobility and the massing of firepower of armored forces. Trapped in column on the road, the Israelis were unable to mass fire on particular targets nor effectively synchronize and coordinate their fires. The short-range engagement, also a characteristic of urban combat, reduced the Israeli armor protection and eliminated the Israeli armor’s ability to keep out of small arms range. Thus, hand-held antiarmor weapons were more effective in an urban area. Additionally, Egyptian small arms and sniper fire critically affected Israeli C2 by successfully targeting leaders. The Egyptian defenders effectively isolated the mounted Israelis by defending and planning engagement areas in depth. The Egyptians synchronized so that they engaged the entire Israeli force simultaneously. This forced the Israelis to fight in multiple directions. It also separated the Israeli infantry from the armor and prevented the formation of combined arms teams necessary for effective urban offensive operations. Suez also demonstrated how civilians come to the advantage of the defense. After the battle was joined, the population—by threatening isolated pockets of Israelis and building barricades—helped prevent the Israelis from reorganizing while in contact and hindered the Israelis breaking contact. The population was also a valuable source of intelligence for the Egyptians and precluded covert Israeli movement in daytime. Suez shows the ability of a well-placed defense in depth to fix a superior force in an urban area. Despite the Israeli commander’s caution to avoid a “Stalingrad,” the Israeli division, brigade, and battalion commanders were quickly trapped and unable to easily break contact. Even a successful defense on the perimeter of the city would not have been nearly as effective, as the Israelis would have easily broken contact once the strength of the defense was recognized. Another key to the success of the Egyptian defense was the Israelis’ inadequate reconnaissance. While the Israelis knew the approximate size of the defending forces, they had no idea of the Egyptian dispositions. In this case, time prevented adequate reconnaissance. Key to a successful defense is adequate security to obscure defense dispositions, which permits surprise and shock effect. The Suez defense was a decisive defeat of elite Israeli forces by regular infantry units inferior in training, morale, and numbers. Total disaster was averted only because of the professionalism of the Israeli armored forces and paratroopers that permitted them to continue to fight and eventually exfiltrate the urban trap. The Israeli forces thus escaped total destruction. Suez strongly demonstrates how the enhancing effects of the urban environment on defensive combat power are significant enough to permit inferior regular forces to defeat elite formations.[/SIZE]
    http://www.fas.org/irp/doddir/army/fm3-06.pdf





    According to the historian Dr Gayrush

  12. #2967
    Senior Member shelata's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Location
    Port Saeid- EGYPT
    Posts
    1,368

    Default

    The heroism of Suez city defenders during 1973 war was recorded in many war references . One of the references that gave detailed description of the fight in the city from an Israeli prospective was the Israeli historian Abraham Rabinovich . In his book the The epic encounter that transformed the middle east a full battle describtion is included. I preferred to paste the respective pages in this post to record the last war battle which, in a way, symbolized accurately the Egyptian army accomplishment in 1973 war.











    Last edited by shelata; 08-12-2011 at 11:30 AM. Reason: wrong english

  13. #2968
    Μολὼν λαβέ Hollis's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 1969
    Location
    Stuck in the rain and mud again.
    Posts
    21,989

    Default

    Shelata if one looks honestly at the war, they will see that there were heroes on both sides. That was for the men and women who served their country not the politicians.

  14. #2969
    Senior Member flanker7's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    cyprus
    Age
    37
    Posts
    8,307

    Default

    I like how this thread stayed reletively civilized. Good thread

  15. #2970
    Senior Member GB_FXST's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Location
    Arizona
    Posts
    6,517

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by shelata View Post
    The heroism of Suez city defenders during 1973 war was recorded in many war references . One of the references that gave detailed description of the fight in the city from an Israeli prospective was the Israeli historian Abraham Rabinovich . In his book the The epic encounter that transformed the middle east a full battle describtion is included. I preferred to paste the respective pages in this post to record the last war battle which, in a way, symbolized accurately the Egyptian army accomplishment in 1973 war.











    That is an abridged version of Chapter 36 of Rabinovich's book.

    You only posted ony a selected sub-set of the larger chapter.

    Proper citation requires you to make note that you have edited your reproduction of Rabinovitch's work. This is not the first time that you are sloppy with cited materials.

    The material you have omitted is not insignificant - and it speaks to the valiant efforts and fighting spirit of the IDF in this difficult battle.

    Rabinovitch, of course, describes the battle for Suez City as a misadventure. But, if you are go to try to use his words to damn the IDF - or make whatever point you are trying to make with that post - at least have the common courtesy to either present his account as he originally published it, or use proper citation so readers are aware that the source contains additional data.

    Twisting his work to suit your thesis is, I guess, just par for the course with you.

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •