Closed Thread
Page 8 of 19
FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 18 ... LastLast
Results 106 to 120 of 277

Thread: HELLENIC AIR FORCE "in action" pictures & videos

  1. #106
    Member orko_8's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Ankara, Turkey
    Posts
    421

    The HUD video of the pursuing Turkish F-16 was released some time after the incident. TuAF pilot screamed "God damn it, he crashed into the sea!". This really was a tragic incident, RIP to the pilot...

    By the way Mirage F1 incident took place on 18.06.1992.. TuAF lost one F-16 in 1992 (on 25.06.1992, near Murted Main Jet Base, pilot survived).

    Video footage taken from a Turkish TV news report about the incident, which has the HUD footage also: http://rapidshare.de/files/20185460/dogfight1.exe.html

  2. #107
    Banned user Scyth's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Ankara, hunting in packs, greyish color
    Posts
    671

    Nice footage Orko. Thanks. I wonder if they have it in higher res?

    As they say, he who plays with fire gets burned.

    RIP to the poor Greek though.

  3. #108
    Member orko_8's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Ankara, Turkey
    Posts
    421

    I have hi-res of the HUD video but not for web / sharing.

    By the way any answers for this?

  4. #109
    Member Nick_Karatzides's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Greece
    Age
    38
    Posts
    942

    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Continuous dogfights over the Aegean have made the THK and HAF some of the most battle-ready air forces in the world.
    That's for sure. All the NATO pilots confirms that these HAF & THK are the most capable pilots nowdays.



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    However, refrain from having hard ons about assassinated Turkish pilots, since the an-eye-for-an-eye rule is applied assiduously on both sides.
    Hmmmm, interesting point of view for the word "assasin". Well, if I (for example) fly armed without your permition, over Turkish territory and you will intercept me and finaly shot me (if I will not follow your "go back" orders)... is that an "assasin"? I bet no! It's an interception! RIP to the poor THK pilot though.



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Greek Mirage-2000s on TAF F-16 HUD
    Sorry no pic! Check, edit and send again if possible.



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    On 8 October 1996, a Greek Mirage 2000 piloted by Thanos Grivas shot down a Turkish F-16D with a Magic IR missile fired on purpose.
    The HAF pilot DID NOT fired without Hdq command! Please see the diference between "assasin" and "interception". According to logic when an "invader" shoots or shot down a "defender" (I remind you that the 1st Lt. (HAF) Nick Sialmas incident dogfight, took place INTO Greek national airspace, over a Greek island) IS a hostile action. I wouldn't say the word "assasin" because these men (both sides) are military pilots and they should be prepared for this. On the other hand, when an "invader" gets shot by a "defender", IS an interception. No?



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Just two days after that murder, on 10 October 1996 a Greek Mirage 2000 crashed close to Semadirek island after a dogfight with two Turkish F-16s.
    What is the Semadirek island? Please give me some infos because it sounds sci-fi to me. We both had some air-to-air loses but no HAF Mirage 2000 ever shot by THK aircrafts.



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    The Greek pilot who shot down the Turkish plane and killed the pilot was tried and convicted. I think he is now spending his days in an asylum for retards right now.
    Is that a joke? Man... I personaly KNOW the guy. I ensure yu that he is one of the most respective "active duty" HAF pilots. Ofcourse had never been convicted and spending his days in an asylum for retards is a quite funny story. Maaaannnn!



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Nick, you're a grown up man, so stop copy-pasting from here: http://www.see.ed.ac.uk/~kap/Aegean/...age/node3.html You have your own views right? And you don't do do propaganda right?
    Skyth, I wonder if you are a grown up man too. For your information the text is copied from HERE (not the also correct link you mention). Also please feel free to check the following:Scyth, you look an openminded person. As I told before propaganda is NOT my way and I'm trying NOT to do! I like seeing the things thay way they ARE (not seem or appear to), with clear DATA and strong FACTS. Now, if you could please give me some advice or links where I can find the REAL 1947 Dodecanese convention and the REAL 1932 convention between Italy and Turkey (if you still believe that "mine" is not real enough for you)... you are mostly welcome to do to give us all an answer.
    Last edited by Nick_Karatzides; 05-12-2006 at 11:47 AM.

  5. #110
    Member Nick_Karatzides's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Greece
    Age
    38
    Posts
    942

    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    As they say, he who plays with fire gets burned. RIP to the poor Greek though.
    Sure! Well it's not good pics but these unlucky THK pilots finaly survived after invading into Greek national airspace and shot down by HAF fighters. They finaly got all the needed medical treatment in Greek hospitals after beeing rescued by Greek SAR helicopters. I hope they are good in their health and still flying.

    As they say, SH!T HAPPENS!

    PS. Did they lost the navigating lessons during the THK academy? They seem to have no idea that they were flying over Greek national airspace. Did they?






    Last edited by Nick_Karatzides; 05-12-2006 at 10:27 AM.

  6. #111
    Banned user Scyth's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2005
    Location
    Ankara, hunting in packs, greyish color
    Posts
    671

    When you SHOOT DOWN a plane in INTERNATIONAL AIRSPACE, its murder. The fact that Greece unilaterally recognizes an expanded airspace is its own problem. The fact that Greece didn't say anything when a Greek plane crashed (not SHOT DOWN mind you, CRASHED or FORCED TO CRASH, you need skill for that, tougher than firing a missile) just two days later, points to the fact the Greek Command accepted having one of its own taken out for compensation to avert war.

    It's a Greek magazine (Krama) that ran an article about that whole event and asserted that Thanos Grivas was tried at a military tribunal and that his mental state was deemed as "unbalanced". Maybe he was acquitted since. Doesn't matter since one of his brother-in-arms lies in his metal grave deep below the Aegean.

    And Nick, you still should'nt copy and paste the works of others as if it was your own. It's intellectual theft and I know you can do better.

    Semadirek is Turkish for Samothraki. The incident I'm referring to is shown on video in Orko's post.

    As for Kardak, I really don't care you know.

  7. #112
    Member Nick_Karatzides's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Greece
    Age
    38
    Posts
    942

    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    When you SHOOT DOWN a plane in INTERNATIONAL AIRSPACE, its murder.
    The THK planes had been shot down INTO Greek national airspace. That's sound like a confirmed interception to me. 1st Lt. (HAF) Nick Sialmas was forced to crash after a dogfight which took place over Greek land and ofcourse INTO Greek national airspace. Well, that's sound like an THK invasion to me. Or maybe assasin?


    I hope our hero 1st Lt. (HAF) Nick Sialmas is now resting in Heaven with his brothers: Leonidas and the spartans.



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    It's a Greek magazine (Krama) that ran an article about that whole event and asserted that Thanos Grivas was tried at a military tribunal and that his mental state was deemed as "unbalanced". Maybe he was acquitted since.
    I say again. I personaly know Thanasis Grivas for more than 15 years. His mental state is not "unbalanced" - after all... he is still flying the Mirage 2000! To tell you the truth, I don't know this Greek magazine named "Krama". Please scan a copy for me and send the page if posible. Are you sure it's a Greek magazine? Does ANY Greek reading here know the magazine "Krama"? If yes, please respond.



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Doesn't matter since one of his brother-in-arms lies in his metal grave deep below the Aegean.
    As I said before, we (REALLY) are very sorry for a human life lost up there. We both had our victims. You also said before: "...he who plays with fire gets burned..."



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Nick, you still should'nt copy and paste the works of others as if it was your own. It's intellectual theft and I know you can do better.
    Skyth, please read again. I have NEVER said that the copy & pasted articles were mine! I always give the links to let the MP readers find their way. I hope you understand. I also know you can do better!



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Just two days after that murder, on 10 October 1996 a Greek Mirage 2000 crashed close to Semadirek island after a dogfight with two Turkish F-16s.
    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    Semadirek is Turkish for Samothraki.
    So Skyth to let me understand: On 10th October 1996 a Greek Mirage 2000 crashed close to Samothraki. I answered before my friend: We both had some air-to-air loses but no HAF Mirage 2000 ever shot (or forced to crash) by THK aircrafts, especialy near Samothraki island! To tell you the truth no HAF Mirage 2000 ever crashed (for ANY reason) close to Samothraki island.



    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth

    As for Kardak, I really don't care you know.
    I thought that discusing polite and using for our conversation the facts stated on international or Greece / Turkey both signed conventions (like 1947 Dodecanese convention and the 1932 convention between Italy and Turkey)... confirms that we are making a nice dialog. Why you are not accepting these documents? Is it a tactic or a fancy trick? I would like to hear your answer if you please.
    Last edited by Nick_Karatzides; 05-12-2006 at 11:48 AM.

  8. #113
    Member CYW's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Larnaca, Cyprus
    Posts
    186

    When you SHOOT DOWN a plane in INTERNATIONAL AIRSPACE, its murder
    And when a country continualy violates another country's airspace no matter how many warnings were given to them, its cause for war...but there u go...

  9. #114
    Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Difficulty taking the finger away from the trigger
    Posts
    722

    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth
    When you SHOOT DOWN a plane in INTERNATIONAL AIRSPACE.
    According to Turkish High Command, Greek waters are also International waters and that is why we have to chase turkish ships too.

  10. #115
    Member Nick_Karatzides's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Greece
    Age
    38
    Posts
    942

    Shooting down of the Turkish F-102s
    on 22nd July 1974

    Originaly written by Mr. Demetris Stergiou found HERE

    Here is an incident that in my opinion is the most important contribution of the Northrop F-5A in the modern history of the Hellenic Air Force. Lets clear that we are talking about the shooting down of a Turkish F-102 by a Greek F-5 on July 21st 1974, and the destruction of a second one. The incident which resulted in two Turkish pilots loosing their lives was recalled by one of the two Greek protagonists, then young pilot and today retired Brigadier General Thomas Skamparthonis.

    "...I reported to the Icarus School (HAF Academy) in October of 1968 and joined the 44th training class. The 44th was the first that completed four years in the Academy, since up to that time the years for graduating were three, as was the same in the Army & Navy Academies. The Icari (cadet pilots) of the 43rd Class, been in the transition stage from three to four years, were sworn as pilot officers at 3 1/2 years and we were the first to be commissioned at 4 years. So I was sworn in as a pilot officer in September of 1972. The years at the Academy passed relatively fast.

    In the first year the basic training was conducted, and this included 35 hours on T-6 Texans and Harvards. We soloed at 25 hours, which is considered late by today's standards, as this was attributed the T-6 being pretty difficult for the young cadets. From the next year (1969-1970) things for the cadets at Icarus School changed with the of the T-41D Mescaleros of the 360th Sqdr. My class, the 44th, was the last to train with the Harvards. In the second year we continued our training with the T-37. At that time we didn't go to Kalamata for this, but to Elefsis. There, the 361st Sqdr. using the T-37 and the 362nd Sqdr. using the T-33A for advanced training were stationed, as wells as the 355MTM. In the second year we concluded our basic training, logging some 70-75 hours, while at the third year, in the advanced stage, we logged 120 hours in the T-33.

    Of course at the time my class was at the advanced stage, Kalamata opened (1970-71), so most T-33 hours were logged there. This change however was not the last for my class. When we reached our fourth year at the Academy, the HAF leadership decided that the Icari should pass another stage of training, called the "operational" and this provided for the conversion on the F-84F and for us to trained in air-to-ground weapons tactics only. We were to use all weapons that the F-84F was capable of using and fire these. At some point the HAF leadership finally decided that this was "risky" despite our significant flying experience gathered the previous three years, so we logged at Larissa the amount of hours necessary (50-60) using the T-33 again. These were Canadian built MkIII's, and were used because of their greater weapon carrying capability.

    I was sworn in as 2nd Lt. in September of 1972 and was transferred to 111th Fighter Wing at Nea Anchialos. At that time the F-5 was used as an unofficial lead-in-fighter training aircraft for newly commissioned pilots that would then transfer to other aircraft, foremost F-104Gs and F-84Fs (the F-104G-units also had two-seaters). I was appointed to 337th Sqdr. a "Day Interceptor" Sqdr, as was the title and the main task of the unit at the time. We had a secondary fighter-bomber role. The operational conversion training for me along with other four of my classmates that were transferred together with me, started immediately, with ground school for the aircraft systems (it was named KEM) and the classes of flight theory, and by the late 1972 / early 1973 we started flying the F-5, going solo after seven hours if I remember correctly.




    Young 1st Lt. (HAF) Thomas Scampardonis seen in front of an F-5A, in the 1970s.

    After 50 hours flown over a span of four to five month, I was declared operational and took part in all the Sqdr. activities. This happened in early summer of 1973. Time passed quickly as that year was full of events, but I have to say that absolutely nothing warned us of what was about to follow in the summer of 1974. Our relations with Turkey seemed and probably were quite good. No reason for scrambles, interceptions and things like that. Of course as a fighter sqdr we always had readiness, but, as far as I can remember in the one year I was operational in the sqdrn, we did not do one single interception of Turkish aircraft. Significantly, only four months before the Turkish invasion of Cyprus, in April of 1974, we visited the THK air base of Bandirma in a squadron exchange program within the NATO. We remained there for ten days, returning the visit made to us by the Turkish F-5s a few months back. I repeat that nothing but really nothing was indicative of what was about to follow in July and August of 1974.



    1st Lt. (HAF) Skampardonis (seen to left) together with a colleague from the 111st Fighter Wing at Nea Anchialos AB

    Even as of July of 1974, with all that happened in Cyprus, we didn't have readiness or alerts, at least not in the Air Force. This I know because the day of the Turkish invasion I was on leave. That morning I went to the balcony to drink my morning coffee when a neighbor informed me that a general mobilization was ordered. Without believing her I opened the television and got the first glimpse of the situation. I packed my things, said "goodbye" to my wife and took my car to the road for Anchialos AB. This took me many more hours than usual since many parts of the Athens - Lamia freeway were closed, so when I finally arrived at my base it was late in the afternoon.

    I was ordered to get into my anti-G suit and done the life vest, and head for the shelter that was assigned to me after a short briefing. The last hours of July 20th passed quietly and from what I am in a position to know there were not any Turkish violations over the Aegean the whole day long.

    The next day, however, things would change. From early morning we had massive violations of the Athens FIR by Turkish aircraft. Me and my colleagues were all inside our aircrafts and waited. Our readiness were of five and two minutes, so we were sitting inside the F-5 cockpit with seatbelts on, waiting for the order to scramble. About 13:30, a scramble was sounded and to my surprise, I was in the first pair to take off. My leader was 1st Lt. (HAF) Dinopoulos, senior than me in the sqdr, serving as an instructor. Without having time to think I started both engines, went out of the shelter, and waited a while to be called by my No.1. This did not happen so I went on the frequency calling my No.1. I haven't got any answer so I taxied on the taxiway waiting for Dinopoulos to lead me to the holding point.

    When he came to the connection point I was in, with a series of hand signals he explained that he had no radio and could neither transmit nor receive anything. With another signal he told me to lead as No.1 and he would follow watching my moves and covering me as a wingman. 1st Lt. (HAF) Dinopoulos should have aborted and return to his shelter actually. This was what our orders provided for in such cases. He didn't do it however and preferred to take-off without me ever knowing the reason for such a decision. I estimate, without being certain, that weighing the situation he followed the unwritten rule that in times of crisis, even with a malfunction, aircraft always take off one way or another. It was certainly a gutsy decision that showed his level of training and professionalism. I went ahead and did exactly what I used to do in training or regular flights without being anxious about anything.




    The first of the two F-5As claimed to have been involved in the incident on 22nd July is the 66-9137, seen here wearing a red line on the fin.

    In our briefings we were specifically ordered to have our weapons switches in the Off position and to do nothing more than a visual ID of the bogeys we would meet. We had no briefing that would indicate that we should be ready for all instances. Of course our unit (111st Fighter Wing) was combat ready with all anti-aircraft guns armed, manned and in position, high security measures etc. So before we took off I knew we would fly a typical interception, a procedure done many timed before in peacetime.

    I followed the instructions of the Mount Pelion radar station (call-sign "Joker") and we started climbing heading for the North Aegean. Dinopoulos followed from a relative long distance flying always higher than me (I don't know exactly how much) in order to be able to watch my movements and the surrounding area. I always followed Joker's instructions that constantly changed my heading and altitude.

    You see, our "targets" were many that day. After two or three such changes of level and heading I was ordered by Joker to head for the area between the islands of Agios Efstratios and Lemnos at a lever of 20000ft. While I was still climbing to about 18000ft with a 350 Knots speed, I was warned by Joker to look for bogeys at 20 degrees right. I turned my attention to that area and almost immediately I saw two Turkish F-102s flying in a tight formation to my left, on a distance no greater than 200 meters. Instinctively and without any delay I stopped climbing, broke hard left and started turning to get behind them. Almost immediately I realized they were doing the same, since I had always visual contact seeing them at my left (8 o'clock). I reported to Joker and to tell you the truth, when I saw them turning behind me I thought they were going to head back east to their base. This, however, did not happen!

    They continued turning in order to get at my 'six and this was evident now. I had full throttle and was on maximum turn rate trying to keep visual contact. In this effort my speed dropped to 300 Knots so I gradually started lowering my nose since we met at the same level but they were in a better position, because they were flying level while I broke my climb.

    After at least four such turns I reported to Joker that I was engaged and continued turning while descending. At a certain point I lost visual contact but I continued turning and looking out my canopy in order to regain visual. Now I was flying at less than 10000ft and as I was looking in all directions I saw at the rather wavy sea water tower climbing very high and then turning in a big oil spill. Then I realised what happened and turned my attention to Dinopoulos trying to locate him. I asked Joker where he was but got back no specific answer.




    The other F-5A involved should have been the 38414, repainted in "Aegean Blue" sheme during the 1980s, and photographed in 1984, in Italy, while on a squadron exchange. According to other sources, the other F-5A from the engagements with THK F-102As was 63-8414, however.

    I was ordered to return to Anchialos and a few moments later I was given a vector for a new bogey that was heading also west like me. I followed Joker's instructions but was unable to find him. Visibility was not that good that day. When I landed, Dinopoulos' aircraft passed over the runway. I stopped at the end of the runway and waited for him to join me. I was surprised to see that both his wingtip Sidewinders were missing. Stoping our aircraft at the apron we got out and before we could say anything to each other we were surrounded by colleagues and technicians asking all kinds of questions. Almost immediately a jeep came and took us away from this pandemonium. We were both questioned separately and returned to our duties. After a while I found out what had happened.

    Dinopoulos was following from a distance and being higher was not seen by the two Turkish pilots. He watched all the engagement descending and closing. Before he could do anything he saw the bay of the leader F-102 open and an AIM-4 Phalcon been fired at me. The missile missed since we were both in a tight sustained turn so they were out of parameters. Without been noticed Dinopoulos closed in range. Let me add here that the target was clearly identified visually. As you know the F-5A had no radar. When you had a visual on the target, you turned the weapons switch on, in the ARM position, selecting guns or missiles. At that time we had only the early AIM-9Bs on our F-5A. A lock-on on the target was achieved when after selecting the missile, and after its seeker head was warmed up and establishing a contact with the hot exhaust gas of the target you heard a screeching sound that was sharper as the seeker head was turning closer to the target. Then you were ready to fire. Distance was calculated visualy also through the gunsight. For example, when the surface of the target was covering all the gunsight, you were 1200 meters away; if the surface was covering half the gunsight, distance was also half etc. If I remember correctly the optimal distance for the AIM-9B was about 800 meters. Having these parameters, Dinopoulos turned the weapon switch ON and fired immediately one Sidewinder.

    The missile was, however, was not ready yet and lacking the time to "warm-up" - missed. The second Sidewinder in the meantime was ready to fire and gave a loud sound signal. Dinopoulos fired the second missile without hesitation. The missile hit dead-center and he had to brake hard right in order to avoid being hit by the debris of the F-102 that was burning while crashing into the sea.




    THK F-102A Delta Dagger seen in the 1970s, and looking the same as the two examples engaged by the Greek fighters on 22nd July 1974.

    The same night we learned that in Turkish television it was reported that two Turkish fighters had shot down two Greek ones. The Greek side did not announce (and did not confirm or deny) anything. Long time after that we learned that the second Turkish pilot (we do not know if he was the No.1 or No.2 of their formation) lost his direction probably due to shock. He was panicked, thought that we were on his tail and made extensive and unnecessary use of his afterburner, thus going "bingo fuel" and finally crash landing on a highway. His aircraft was destroyed and he died of his injuries later at the hospital.

    We also learned that the Turkish pilots were probably high ranking ones and we got word that the leader was a Lt. Colonel, and his wingman a Major. After this, nothing happened: there were no news. We returned to normal pace and the Turks did not show up over the Aegean even at the second phase of the Cyprus invasion in August 1974. What changed that day was that from now on Greek fighters always took off with the weapons switches in the ON position and that the Turks did not show up over the Aegean for years. And when I say years, I mean years. From what I am in a position to know, their first hesitant attempts to fly over the area were done in 1976 - 1977.

    Many years later I was serving in Naples, at Air-South Command, when a Turkish pilot approached me and we started to talk. When he stared to tell me about the capabilities of his country's Air Force, he mentioned that the Turkish F-102's shot down two Greek F-5's. When I asked him if I look like a zombie he changed colour. I have never seen a more embarrassed man in my life...
    "


    Brig. Gen. Thomas Skampardonis describing the head-on pass during the engagement with two THK F-102As while bieng interviewed by Demetrius Stergiou.

    Even if some say that the Greek pilots involved in this incident were mistreated by HAF General Staff, and were not given the proper promotions, Thomas Skamparthonis denied this strongly. He did not deny however that both he and Dinopoulos were not given any medal or commendation for their combat. From our point of view we believe that not going public and recognizing this incident is not the right way, especially since the Turkish side still claims - foremost through the internet that their F-102s shot down the Greek F-5's!

    That the "other side" has always maintained an affection for propaganda and winning the last impression, is well known, even if some Greeks in key positions cannot or are not willing to understand it. It is almost certain that the same tactic will be continued in the future. Is it not time for HAF to end its silence and state the facts? Twenty seven years have passed and we believe this should be done soon!

    The AIM-4 carried by the Turkish F-102's were probably of the D version, fielded in 1963 for use against fighter aircraft. However, we can only be sure that the missile was practically useless in air combat within the visual distances, especially under the specific conditions that the Turkish pilot used it in: sustained turn at maximum degrees and high G's. It is certain that despite the improvements of this version, kinetically it was almost the same missile as the C version, intended for use against the Soviet bombers, not in manoeuvring combat against enemy fighters.

    The date has been confirmed by numerous other HAF pilots who were in the air that day, especially 339th Mira F-4E pilots, Air Vice Marshalls (Ret.):
    • Air Vice Marshall (HAF Ret.) Panagiotis Mpalles
    • Air Vice Marshall (HAF Ret.) Stephanos Skrekas,
    • Air Vice Marshall (HAF Ret.) George Skarlatos,
    • Air Vice Marshall (HAF Ret.) Panagiotis Manousos,
    • Member of Parliament, Minister of Defence and Colonel (HAF Ret.) Spilios Spiliotopoulos.
    Also we have the report by the then Colonel (HAF) P. Semertzakis who studied all official HAF reports during the invasion of Cyprus and was submitted in December 1974 to the PA General Staff, and which analysed all aspects of the aerial operations. The Greek MoD George Averoff, member of the civilian Government that lead the Country to free democratic elections in the fall of 1974, during his meeting with State Departments Undersecretary of State Hartman, also mentioned the 22nd July as the date of this engagement.
    Last edited by Nick_Karatzides; 05-11-2006 at 03:39 PM.

  11. #116
    Member Nick_Karatzides's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Greece
    Age
    38
    Posts
    942

    Quote Originally Posted by Skyth

    Just two days after that murder, on 10 October 1996 a Greek Mirage 2000 crashed close to Semadirek island after a dogfight with two Turkish F-16s.
    Quote Originally Posted by Skyth

    Semadirek is Turkish for Samothraki.
    My friend Skyth, as I explained before and according the known sources, no HAF Mirage 2000 ever been shotdown (or forced to crash) by THK aircrafts, especialy near Samothraki island (which is Greek island)! To tell you the truth no HAF Mirage 2000 ever crashed (for ANY reason) close to Samothraki island. I don't know why you claim that on 10th October 1996 a Greek Mirage 2000 crashed close to Samothraki.

    I propose to click HERE to get a link (sorry only in Greek language for the moment) where you can get the official catalog with ALL the HAF casualities, major fatal accidents and pilot losses since 1980 until our days (2006). I copied that to present it for MP member might be interested on this spesific point:

    2006
    • Dassault Mirage 2000 14/04/2006


    2004
    • Lockheed Martin F-16C Fighting Falcon 14/10/2004
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 16/06/2004


    2003
    • PZL Okecie M-18BS Dromader 25/08/2003


    2002
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 27/06/2002


    2000
    • Lockheed Martin F-16C Fighting Falcon 13/11/2000
    • PZL Okecie M-18BS Dromader 08/08/2000
    • Bombardier Canadair CL-215 15/07/2000
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 18/05/2000
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 17/05/2000
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 17/01/2000


    1999
    • Northrop F-5A Freedom Fighter 05/07/1999


    1998
    • Dassault Mirage 2000 04/11/1998
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 20/08/1998
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 13/08/1998


    1997
    • Lockheed C-130 Hercules 20/12/1997
    • Dassault Mirage 2000 30/09/1997
    • Lockheed Martin F-16C Fighting Falcon 23/09/1997
    • Northrop F-5A Freedom Fighter 28/07/1997


    1996
    • Vought T-2E Buckeye 24/06/1996
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 10/01/1996


    1995
    • Northrop F-5A Freedom Fighter 01/02/1995
    • Northrop F-5B Freedom Fighter 01/02/1995


    1994
    • Dassault Mirage F-1CG 07/11/1994


    1993
    • Bombardier Canadair CL-215 22/08/1993


    1992
    • Lockheed Martin F-16C Fighting Falcon 26/11/1992
    • Dassault Mirage F-1CG 18/06/1992
    • Grumman HU-16B ASW 23/01/1992
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 07/01/1992


    1991
    • Douglas C-47 Dakota Mk IV 27/12/1991
    • Lockheed T-37 Tweety Bird 04/06/1991
    • Lockheed C-130 Hercules 05/02/1991


    1990
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 07/03/1990


    1989
    • Agusta Bell AB-205 10/05/1989
    • Lockheed T-33A Shooting Star 07/03/1989


    1988
    • Northrop RF-5A Freedom Fighter 14/09/1988
    • Dassault Mirage F-1CG 10/02/1988


    1987
    • Northrop F-5A Freedom Fighter 16/12/1987
    • Lockheed F-104G Starfighter 23/09/1987
    • Agusta Bell AB-205 26/07/1987
    • Mc Donnell Douglas RF-4E Phantom II 07/05/1987
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 22/01/1987


    1986
    • Grumman G-164 AgCat 02/10/1986


    1985
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 11/09/1985
    • Mc Donnell Douglas RF-4E Phantom II 11/07/1985
    • Lockheed T-33A Shooting Star 05/04/1985


    1984
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 10/05/1984
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 02/05/1984
    • Bombardier Canadair CL-215 09/03/1984


    1983
    • Northrop F-5A Freedom Fighter 14/09/1983
    • Vought T-2E Buckeye 28/07/1983
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 08/07/1983
    • Dassault Mirage F-1CG 26/04/1983


    1982
    • Mc Donnell Douglas F-4E Phantom II 15/12/1982
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 23/07/1982
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 29/06/1982


    1981
    • Lockheed T-33A Shooting Star 18/12/1981
    • Dassault Mirage F-1CG 18/11/1981
    • Vought LTV A-7 Corsair II 13/08/1981


    1980
    • Dassault Mirage F-1CG 06/06/1980
    • Northrop RF-5A Freedom Fighter 23/05/1980
    • Lockheed TF-104G Starfighter 15/04/1980
    • Lockheed TF-104G Starfighter 15/01/1980
    As we all can see, there is no HAF Dassault Mirage 2000 loss on 10th October 1996, or any other date in 1996.



    Skyth,

    After some internet search, I found a related topic on f-16.net about the THK F-16 shot down by a HAF Mirage 2000 and ANY possible Turkish revenge action, two days later as you claim). I copy & paste the text as presented into f-16.net source:

    "...4 Turkish F-4Es from 112 Seytan filo based in Eskisehir was on CAP training mission over Aegean. As usual, 2 Greek Mirage 2000s took off from their forward base and turned towards F-4Es.


    At the same time, another 2 Turkish F-16s (one C and one D) were on a training mission near F-4Es too and "were not armed" that time. the Turkish ground controller directed these 2 F-16s towards Greek Mirage 2000s to intercept them before the Mirage 2000s reach F-4Es. As usual, 2 side merged and dogfight started, little later it turn to 1 on 1 engagement. The Turkish F-16D piloted by
    Captain Nail Erdogan engaged with 1st Lt (HAF) Thanasis Grivas. The back seater in Turkish F-16D was Col Cemil Cicekli just returned from 2 years of military attache duty in UK and was in refresher trainig with squadron IP Captain Nail Erdogan. After trying to gain advantage on each other, in a head on pass, Grivas fired a Magic II and shot F-16D. It caused an explosion and put F-16D in fire ball. Force of the explosion forced Col Cemil Cicekli out of cockpit without pulling ejection handle, Captain Nail Erdogan did not have time to eject and was probably killed instantly. The F-16D crashed 10 miles off Chios island (Greek area) and Col Cemil Cicekli rescued by Greek SAR helo. Col Cemil Cicekli was in a shock after the incident and did not talk to Greeks too much. Strangely, Greeks thought he can not be Turkish since he speaks good English, someone (HAF officers) in Greece claimed he could be a IDF pilot in squadron exchange program. This whole incident went to AFM and discussed several times in the past. After Col Cemil Cicekli returned to Turkey, he said that 1st Lt (HAF) Thanasis Grivas visited him in the hospital. Greeks claimed that F-16D was violating Greek air space and 1st Lt (HAF) Thanasis Grivas have had right to fire. But air space violations are two sided, sometimes HAF also violates Turkish national air space. It happened in the past and it can happen in the future too. IF ROE is applied, every single interception can turn bloody and each side can fire... but fortunatley this did not happened in the past, will not happen in the future too. Usual encounters in Aegean are just to show off pilot skills to other side and go home..."


    Mirage 2000EGM s/n "220" is said to have been the example used to shot down a THK F-16D in October 1996. There are rumours that the aircraft wore some kind of a kill marking for some time, but these were never entirely confirmed.



    Turkish F-16C as seen through the HUD of a Greek Mirage 2000EGM

    According some Turk f-16.net members, the following article was published into the Turkish Daily News Online link HERE, but I could not finaly manage to make the link open and read the article directly from the Turkish Daily News Online - so I cannot confirm the source. I copy & paste the text written by Turk f-16.net member:

    "...The Turkish F-16 crash in the Aegean on Oct. 8 1996 in which Captain Nail Erdogan was martyred while Col Cemil Cicekli survived the crash, resulted from a dogfight. The incident was covered up. The Turkish General Staff announced that the plane had crashed during a training flight. Two days later it was announced that a Mirage 2000 warplane belonging to the Greek Air Force crashed in the Aegean. Reportedly, the Greek warplane was shot down by a Turkish warplane in reprisal for this incident..."

    While searching on Turks.us, I found the following article which is also published HERE:

    "...The family of a Captain Nail Erdogan who was killed in a dog fight in the Aegean Sea, sued Athens, at the European Court for Human Rights. Pilot Captain Nail Erdogan was killed in a F-16 during the flight over the Aegean on 8 October 1996. The petition of his family to the ECHR has been accepted by the court. The family of Captain Nail Erdogan demanded 625 thousand Euro as compensation and 4 million Euro to find the body of the young man. Captain Nail Erdogan was killed in a dog fight with Greek fighters while Col Cemil Cicekli survived. Years later, a Greek magazine wrote that the incident was not an accident and the Greek Mirage aircraft had hit and downed the Turkish war plane, with missiles. The ECHR which accepted the petition gave a time to both sides to furnish their evidence. The Attorney of the Erdogan family, Mehmet Emin Keles said that they had petitioned to ECHR against the pilot of the Mirage, Thanos Grivas, that downed the Turkish aircraft on grounds of “Murder”, because “He took a live when there was no state of war.” Last May, Greek Karma magazine had revealed the death of the Turkish pilot by a Greek missile. The evidence furnished by the Turkish family at the case at ECHR, was a picture printed by the Greek magazine, which showed that the Greek Mirage which downed the Turkish aircraft, had a small picture of a Turkish flag at its nose, showing that it had downed the Turkish aircraft...."

    This is what was written on Greek news about the incident. Found HERE:

    "...Family of ‘downed’ Turk to sue. ANKARA (AFP) - Relatives of a Turkish air force pilot killed in 1996 when his jet was lost over the Aegean Sea want compensation from Greece, which they accuse of downing the plane, the family’s lawyer said yesterday. On October 8, 1996, Turkey announced the loss of an F-16 during an Aegean training mission, in what Ankara said was international air space north of Samos. One of the pilots managed to eject and was rescued, but the other, Captain Nail Erdogan, 35, was killed. The Turkish Milliyet daily recently quoted a former air force chief, General Ahmet Corekci, as saying the plane was downed by a missile fired by a Greek fighter. Athens has denied this. 'The right to life was violated... to obtain moral and material compensation we shall shortly be bringing an action against Greece' before the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, Mehmet Emin Keles told AFP. He said the suit would also seek recovery of Erdogan’s plane and body from the sea. Yesterday, Turkish press reports said Erdogan’s family would be asking for 2 trillion Turkish liras (just over a million euros) in compensation...."

    According to the nowdays FACTS and DATA, there was not any possible Mirage 2000 shot down after the Oct. 8th 1996 incident. It seems like a rumours spread out by some Turkish newspapers in order to compensate Turkish public's appetite for retaliation, which reminds me EXACTLY the same fake Turkish reactions after the Turkish F-102s shooting down incident on 22nd July 1974 as described in message #115 before. I copy & paste the specific Brigadier General Thomas Skamparthonis interview parts again, in order to remind:

    "...The same night we learned that in Turkish television it was reported that two Turkish fighters had shot down two Greek ones..."

    and

    "...many years later I was serving in Naples, at AirSouth Command, when a Turkish pilot approached me and we started to talk. When he stared to tell me about the capabilities of his country's Air Force, he mentioned that the Turkish F-102's shot down two Greek F-5's. When I asked him if I look like a zombie he changed colour. I have never seen a more embarrassed man in my life..."

    Quote Originally Posted by Scyth
    • On 12 June 1992, a Greek Mirage F-1C crashed during a dogfight with a Turkish F-16 piloted by Capt. Ilhan Filiz.
    • On 8 October 1996, a Greek Mirage-2000 piloted by Thanos Grivas shot down a Turkish F-16D with a Magic IR missile fired on purpose.
    • Just two days after that murder, on 10 October 1996 a Greek Mirage-2000 crashed close to Semadirek island after a dogfight with two Turkish F-16s.
    Point of the story is: TUAF saved itself two missiles.
    Well, according all the above stories (including the HAF F-5s vs THK Turkish F-102s described in message #115, THK F-16 vs HAF Mirage F-1CG described in message #104, HAF Mirage 2000 vs THK F-16 described into the present message) the way I see it, is that HAF may spend some money on firing the GAR8 missiles but this aerial madness cost THK a little more while lost more money by loosing more aircrafts and pilots.

    The most important is that HUMAN LIFES are lost both sides... and this is not wise!
    Last edited by Nick_Karatzides; 05-12-2006 at 01:31 PM.

  12. #117
    Banned user Kontra1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    1,608

    Quote Originally Posted by Nick_Karatzides
    Kontra1, thanks for posting. You are very welcome into HELLENIC AIR FORCE "in action" pictures & videos topic. To tell you the truth I was wondering why you didn't post any pics or comments so long. Please allow me to answer on your kind questions / statements, one by one:
    Thanks for the welcome

    NOBODY denies the 1st Lt. (HAF) Nick Sialmas event. But I think that you are not informed as well as you should. First of all, it happened on 18th June 1992 (not 12th June 1992 as you said). The [FONT=Verdana]1st Lt. (HAF) Nick Sialmas event, was NOT a reaction of any THK aircraft loss. It happened after a very long period of time where both AFs had only "virtual" wins and no real casualities - that's for sure! You can get a full detailed "air-to-air victories" catalog by clicking HERE
    Niko..this is the second time you do this...you quote the things I havent said and this kind of makes me loose my interest in respoding your posts more seriously.You see.... I don't see any any dates in my own post, yet you claim that I gave a date and give the 12 June 1992. All I said was "According my sources, 1996 shooting down of a THK F-16(Oct.8 1996) was followed by crashing down of a Greek Mirage(some sources indicates it's a F1 some Mirage2000) only two days after(Oct. 10th) our F-16 incident during a another one of those dogfights...so even the pilot's name can be mixed up since all kept secret for the sake of the peace between the two countries and went down to HAF's files as "accident"

    All this was brought up recently in that Greek magasine "Krama" by the Greek journalist I've mentioned before(I think he's the owner of the paper)

    I also tried to read the rest of your copy/paste post..like I say "I tried" because it's pure Greek propaganda and not objective at all.

    So, although my response to your propaganda will be an copy/paste post also, at least it is from a a lot more objective and logical source...not emotional propaganda source like yours. I'm sure any right minded person will see the difference between a propaganda and the international understandings and rules and make their own conclutions(of course greeks can be kept out of this expectation) I Know you and other greeks will defend you have the right to do this now according to the most recent LOS convention, but so far all the greeks I've exchanged conversation with regarding this matter, fail to mention the special exceptions on the same convention that applies to situations such as we have in the Aegean sea.

    The expansion of the Greek territorial sea to 12-nm will pose a threat to the freedom of navigation currently enjoyed in the Aegean Sea. An expanded Greek territorial sea will convert approximately 70% of the Aegean to Greek territorial seas. Under the regime established by the LOS Convention, Greece believes it has the authority to regulate the application of transit passage through the Aegean, including designation of the international straits through with the right of transit passage will apply. Other waters, in Greek eyes are territorial seas in which the more limited right of innocent passage would apply. This would end overflight and submerged passage throughout the Aegean. Such a declaration will not be accepted by the maritime nations of the world, especially Turkey. Greek enforcement of that declaration is likely to splinter NATO, bring Greece and Turkey into conflict, and cause the U.S. to bring our national power to bear to keep the navigational freedoms envisioned by the LOS Convention available.

    http://www.stormingmedia.us/86/8633/A863393.html

    Also another objective explanation of the Kardak situation.

    Imia-Kardak crisis
    The Imia-Kardak crisis was a conflict that arose between Turkey and Greece in the Aegean Sea in 1996. Kardak Rocks (Imia in Greek, sometimes referred to as İkizce in Turkish) are two tiny islets that lie in the Aegean Sea, 3.8 nautical miles (about 7 km) off the Mugla Province, on the southwestern coast of Turkey, and 5.5 nautical miles (about 10 km) off the Greek island of Kalymnos. Their total surface area is 10 acres (about 40,000 m2).
    Overview
    A Turkish bulk carrier ran ashore the Kardak/Imia rocks on 25 December, 1995. As the maritime boundary between Turkey and Greece has never been thoroughly defined, during the salvage operations of the ship, the sovereignty issue over these islets arose. This issue had not been discussed at any time in either the Greek or Turkish media, or had never been a matter of dispute in the sometimes tender political climate between these countries earlier.
    The event was not known to either the Greek or the Turkish public until a month later, when the Greek periodical GRAMMA ran a story on 20 January, 1996, one day after Costas Simitis was appointed to form the new Greek government as prime minister. The article brought severe reaction from the Greek press, which was followed by the mayor of Kalymnos and a priest hoisting up a Greek flag on the rocks on 26 January, which held no man-made constructions. As opposed to this action, some Turkish journalists and TV anchors flew to the islet with a helicopter and raised a Turkish flag, bringing down the Greek one, the whole events being broadcast live on Turkish television stations. In 24 hours, by 30 January, the Greek navy changed the flag, which resulted in exchange of fierce statements lead by the Turkish Prime Minister Tansu Ciller and the Greek Prime Minister Simitis. A Greek helicopter crashed (some speculating due to Turkish fire), but this was concealed by both states http://www.greekhelsinki.gr/pdf/Greek-Turkish-Media.PDF to prevent further escalation. Turkish and Greek naval forces were alerted and warships of both countries, both NATO members, sailed to the islets.


    Read the rest here:

    http://www.reference.com/browse/wiki/Imia-Kardak_crisis

    P.S. The last time we disgussed the Cyprus situation over here the thread got locked b/o you guys...I see you've spread the propaganda about it here and there in yor posts, but if you promise us you'll be able to handle the truth about it, I can definetely start posting my responses to your claims...OK
    Last edited by Kontra1; 05-11-2006 at 04:51 PM.

  13. #118
    Member Nick_Karatzides's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    Greece
    Age
    38
    Posts
    942

    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    Niko..this is the second time you do this...you quote the things I havent said and this kind of makes me loose my interest in respoding your posts more seriously. You see.... I don't see any any dates in my own post, yet you claim that I gave a date and give the 12 June 1992.
    Kontra1, you are right. I apologise for this "wrong date" misunderstanding. I should speak to Skyth (banned user?) who claimed the 12nd June 1992 date instead of the 18th June 1992.



    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    All this was brought up recently in that Greek magazine "Krama" by the Greek journalist I've mentioned before(I think he's the owner of the paper)
    As I said before, I REALLY don't know this Greek magazine named "Krama". Never seen it before! Mr. Panos Kolyopanos who seems to be the author, is also not known to me. When did this magazine (Krama) ran this article about the HAF Mirage 2000 vs THK F-16 event? Is it possible scan a copy for me and send the page? I ask again: Does ANY Greek reading here know the magazine "Krama" or Mr. Panos Kolyopanos? If yes, please respond. Seems quite strange to me that I couldn't find anything about him after an internet search (except some texs written in Turkish language). Who is that guy and what is that magazine after all?



    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    I also tried to read the rest of your copy/paste post..like I say "I tried" because it's pure Greek propaganda and not objective at all.
    As I told many times before (makes me loose my interest in respoding your posts more seriously), propaganda is NOT my way and I'm trying NOT to do! I like seeing the things thay way they ARE (not seem or appear to), with clear DATA and strong FACTS. I tried to copy & paste text from openminded, non - propaganda links that seem (so far) to establish serious History and politics analyzing. So, what EXACTLY is the point which is not OK with you?



    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    The expansion of the Greek territorial sea to 12-nm will pose a threat to the freedom of navigation currently enjoyed in the Aegean Sea. An expanded Greek territorial sea will convert approximately 70% of the Aegean to Greek territorial seas. Under the regime established by the LOS Convention, Greece believes it has the authority to regulate the application of transit passage through the Aegean, including designation of the international straits through with the right of transit passage will apply. Other waters, in Greek eyes are territorial seas in which the more limited right of innocent passage would apply. This would end overflight and submerged passage throughout the Aegean. Such a declaration will not be accepted by the maritime nations of the world, especially Turkey. Greek enforcement of that declaration is likely to splinter NATO, bring Greece and Turkey into conflict, and cause the U.S. to bring our national power to bear to keep the navigational freedoms envisioned by the LOS Convention available.

    Understood! It's obvious. I can clearly see the reasons that Turkish worries. I would be worried too if I was a Turk and I would fight against it too. But... what is the conection with the subject we are discusing? Did I ever said something else? No! As I said before, Greece has this strange shape, and it's east border with Turkey is currently the Aegean islands, the Dodecanese are a few of them. These remote islands are closer to the Turkish coast compared to the Greek main land. This is not strange, because the west Turkish coast of Asia Minor was inhabited by Greeks. These islands is what remains of the original Greek boarders. The Turks were in all their history impotent in the naval fight for that reason all the Aegean sea is Greek. Yet in the recent years there was oil found in the Aegean sea, since 1974 Turkey started being interested in the Aegean sea. The new claim Turkey raised was that the islands do not have a continental plate, therefore the Aegean oil is Turkish regardless the fact that all the islands in the Aegean sea are Greek. In other words the Greek islands lay on a Turkish continental plate, or the oil of the north sea does not belong partly to England and Scotland, because Great Britain is an island! Moreover according to the law about the sea of 1982, the territorial waters expanded form 10 to 12 miles. This means that Turkey will be blocked by the numerous Greek islands, and the Turks will need the Greek license to exit in the Mediterranean. For that reason Turkey stated that if Greece extends its sea borders to 12 miles, it will be an act of war. Greece until recently have not extended it's territorial waters, but it will do so in the future, therefore Turkey is interested in occupying some Greek islands in order to maintain the exit to the Mediterranean.



    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    Imia-Kardak crisis: The Imia-Kardak crisis was a conflict that arose between Turkey and Greece in the Aegean Sea in 1996. Kardak Rocks (Imia in Greek, sometimes referred to as İkizce in Turkish) are two tiny islets that lie in the Aegean Sea, 3.8 nautical miles (about 7 km) off the Mugla Province, on the southwestern coast of Turkey, and 5.5 nautical miles (about 10 km) off the Greek island of Kalymnos. Their total surface area is 10 acres (about 40,000 m2).
    Correct, so far. Already said the same things into my message, so I don't stay more on these geography lessons.



    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    As the maritime boundary between Turkey and Greece has never been thoroughly defined, during the salvage operations of the ship, the sovereignty issue over these islets arose.
    Wrong! Here we go again.

    The maritime boundaries between Greece and Turkey are VERY CLEARLY defined! Any reason to deny these both side agreed boundaries?

    The maritime boundaries between Greece and Turkey had been VERY CLEARLY defined by the based on 1947 Dodecanese convention and the 1932 convention between Italy and Turkey documents signed by all nations after WWII. These documents are the living proof. These islands, as you can see on this official US Navy map, are within the boundaries of the Greek State and (as said before into my previous messages) it would be interesting to note that the official maps of the Italian, the British and the US Navy include the isle of Imia to the Greek territory. Even the official Turkish maps (which was last updated in 1953) does NOT include the isle in Turkey.



    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    The mayor of Kalymnos and a priest hoist up a Greek flag on the rocks on 26 January, which held no man-made constructions. As opposed to this action, some Turkish journalists and TV anchors flew to the islet with a helicopter and raised a Turkish flag, bringing down the Greek one, the whole events being broadcast live on Turkish television stations.
    Please Kontra1. Please tell me the truth. Do you REALLY believe these excuses? Do you? Even if (sci-fi scenario) a mayor and a priest hoist up a Greek flag on the rocks of a Greek island witout man-made constructions... is that a reason to "send" some Turkish "journalists" and TV anchors to the islet with a helicopter and raised a Turkish flag, bringing down the Greek one while broadcasting live on Turkish television stations? You may know that Greece has MORE than 3500 islands into the Aegean sea - some of them much smaller than Imia. It is imposible to raise a flag 24/7/365 on all of them! Why this specific "interest" for this specific isle? Is it the isle? No... no, it's something more.



    Quote Originally Posted by Kontra1

    In 24 hours, by 30 January, the Greek Navy changed the flag
    I'm sure that Turkish Naval forces would do exactly the same (the should do), if "somebody" - especialy a citizen "journalist" - would bringing down the Turkish flag from a Turkish land, from a Turkish territory accepted by ALL nations, while broadcasting live on Greek TV. I remember a very well known incident happened only few years before, where "someone" SHOOT & KILL "someone else" just because he tried to climb on the Turkish flag mast and take it down, into Turkish territory. I'm very sure you understand very well what I'm talking about and how SERIOUS is to see your national flag while bringing down by the "other side".

    The Greek thesis is:
    • Greece claims that the meeting minutes of the Ankara convention should be considered having the force of a treaty, and a reference to Imia rocks made in one of these minutes is in effect.
    • The Greek thesis also asserts that the Imia rocks are linked to the Dodecanese chain (that they were adjacent islets), and were ceded by Turkey to Greece through Italy with the respective treaties.
    • According to Greece, Imia rocks have existed within its administrative structure since 1948 (Greek law dated 1948, no. 547), they have been included in the Greek territory in both Greek and international maps with the names Limnia or Imia since then, and that Turkey has not disputed these until 1995.
    The Turkish thesis is:
    • Turkey denies the Greek thesis as "unacceptable" and claims that the relevant minutes referencing to the Imia rocks were not signed, as opposed to the other minutes, and therefore they do not have the force of a treaty.
    • Turkey also insists that the islands ceded to Italy with the 1932 Dodecanese treaty were explicitly mentioned by name, and did not include the disputed rocks.
    • Turkey claims that the maps with Limnia/Imia depicted as Kardak rocks merely stand as Greek propaganda and that international maps showing the rocks to be under Turkish sovereignty and with their Turkish name also exist.
    I can surely understand that expansion of the Greek territorial sea to 12-nm will pose a very serious threat for the Turkish interests. It is your job to consider it and worry about, but it's also obvious that these incidents (for example Imia crisis) never happened just because of some TV "journalists". As a conclusion, the Greeks are accepting the Imia islands as GREEK only under the facts stated on international or Greece / Turkey both signed conventions (like the 1947 Dodecanese convention and the 1932 convention between Italy and Turkey). On the other Turkish side keeps denying the signed papers and documents. Still believe in the same old "Greek propaganda" excuse too?

    So, considering that this is a HELLENIC AIR FORCE "in action" pictures & videos topic, I would like to see your "in action" HAF pics or your kind comments about the above stories (including the HAF F-5s vs THK Turkish F-102s described in message #115, THK F-16 vs HAF Mirage F-1CG described in message #104, HAF Mirage 2000 vs THK F-16 described into the #116 message).
    Last edited by Nick_Karatzides; 05-12-2006 at 08:12 AM.

  14. #119
    Banned user DeathForSale's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2004
    Age
    24
    Posts
    1,339

    Great picture brothers keep it up!

    Don't worry about Scyth the Turk he's been banned for life.

  15. #120
    Member saladin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    Support UNICEF to do some good: http://tinyurl.com/3sl8zb
    Posts
    744

    Quote Originally Posted by Nick_Karatzides
    Sure! Well it's not good pics but these unlucky THK pilots finaly survived after invading into Greek national airspace and shot down by HAF fighters. They finaly got all the needed medical treatment in Greek hospitals after beeing rescued by Greek SAR helicopters. I hope they are good in their health and still flying.
    I thought the instructor pilot was an Israeli. You know Turks do not have any good intructors so they import them. But you see, I don't know how to believe you guys any more. Until a few months ago, all the greeks were agreeing that the pilot in the picture was an Israeli. Now did he turn out the be a Turk after all?

    Also, could some body let me know the first rule of the air engagements. I tthought it was to shoot first and kill first.

    Lets imagine a scenerio, GoodGuyOne and GoodGuyTwo are against BadGuyAlpha and BadGuyBeta. Both GoodGuys are at their opponents' six. In real war, they shoot and they kill. HUD pictures from BadGuys show the bottom of the Agean sea. In a simulated dog fight, both GoodGuys engage their enemies as they did in the real war, but they don't have the means to kill them this time. What happens next? BadGuyBeta goes to the six of GoodGuyOne which is following BadGuyAlpha. The results? The HUD pictures all over the internet showing that BadGuys had a kill. The moral of the story, never believe propoganda pictures.

Closed Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts